The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Miang]

Hello!

I wanted to ask if this trade would be fair? I am still trying to figure out what more demanded/ex list pets are worth atm! If this is not fair, what am I missing/ what would I need to add?

(the 2019 rereleases are from 2010,
The vr nick is from 2009)
Thank you so much!

[Ucanthandleme]

Could I get a second opinion on these store pet trades? Thank you!
(1)
(2)
For 1, my partner is willing to add C$ (40 is their initial offer). For 2 my partner said in their message they're also willing to add to their side. I don't usually like trading down in date (except I am seeking/allowing trade downs for the deer offered in 2) so I'm a bit unsure about these!

Well let me try my hand at this,

2020 Stores: Late ‘10 rare
2019 Stores: Mid ‘10 rare
2018 Stores: Early ‘10 rare
2017 Stores: Late ‘09 rare
2016 Stores: Mid ‘09 rare
2015 Stores: Early ‘09 rare
2014 Stores: 2 ‘09 rares
2013 Stores: 3-4 ‘09 rares
2012 Stores: 1 Mid advent, 7-8 ‘09 rares
2011 Stores: 1.5 mid advents, 10 ‘09 rare

trade 1

Your side 2 09' rares

Their side early 09' rare + 40c$ (which could account for the missing 09' rare maybe a bit on the lower end ; 35-55c$ for a 2009 rare/very rare).

I personally wouldn't do this trade due to the fact most older rares that people sell for c$ are low demand pets. If you are seeking that specific store pet I would see if they would be willing to add a higher demand 09' rare instead of c$.

trade 2

Your side
Early ‘09 rare and Mid 09' rare.

Their side
Late ‘09 rare, 1 Early ‘10 rare,
due to the fact the other 2 18' store pets are rare I'm valuing them at a mid ‘10 rare, this is up to each individual so you can choose how to value them,
Mid 10' rare
So their side is worth around 3 09' rares ( 2 10' rates = 1 09' rare).
So technically they are overpaying but again I would keep the older store pets due to the fact it will be hard to trade back up again.




So I would not do the first one unless they would be willing to do a 09' rare instead of c$, and the second one is really up to you it is fair if not them slightly overpaying but it would be hard to trade back up.

Feel free to get a second opinion and correct me if I'm wrong.

[bugbaby]

hello trade thread i come to ask once again which of these offers is worth more, not for one of my pets but an art auction

this + this is one total offer, a lot of old pets, ps im trying to collect every butterfly wolf so that's what most of these trades consist of lmao

this is the other offer, obviously i'm really interested in the 2009 staff birthday bwolf but idk which is worth more in total

[Purpledomo9]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91162419&userid=994914&signature=5q4b6ZXLKUg9d1vTvKpk5Q
What does this look like for auction terms? ^^

this isnt fair at all to you, especially on auction terms. you have a 2015 store pet, and them offering two newer store pets that arent even the same rarity isnt fair. i'd say not to accept, but its totally up to you and what youre looking for.

[TheMamba]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91168112&userid=947496&signature=C8XVmuDdqel5sxWPZlx4Uw

2009 rerelease, is this fair? First time trading a vr

[Wookieinmashoo]

Would any of these bids be good for the dog? I'm looking for tradeable uncommons between 2019 and 2017 though 2020 is also fine

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91162560&userid=245926&signature=1fERSaFmH0eEiSu7k8jzAg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165297&userid=245926&signature=qivJ3Pytbjvx30tWdjXJiA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91166561&userid=245926&signature=AYTA4DDbobNe3Wq8P9cWvw

[GekkoCrazyy]

Opinions?

[weld]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91151476&userid=815492&signature=a1bKT43CE7wlbdIdGVbz9Q
is this fair?

edit:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91157380&userid=815492&signature=BjdyDWsBqDTFzW0HL947qA
this too?

second opinion??

[bugbaby]

hello trade thread i come to ask once again which of these offers is worth more, not for one of my pets but an art auction

this + this is one total offer, a lot of old pets, ps im trying to collect every butterfly wolf so that's what most of these trades consist of lmao

this is the other offer, obviously i'm really interested in the 2009 staff birthday bwolf but idk which is worth more in total

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91168112&userid=947496&signature=C8XVmuDdqel5sxWPZlx4Uw

2009 rerelease, is this fair? First time trading a vr

09s are worth 35-55, but considering that pet is an EARLY (I believe february) 2009 pet, and a VR instead of a regular rare, I'd value it towards the higher end of that; at least 45 if not more. Might be a bit more challenging to get that amount because it's a rat, but the species doesn't decrease its value or rarity.

hello trade thread i come to ask once again which of these offers is worth more, not for one of my pets but an art auction

this + this is one total offer, a lot of old pets, ps im trying to collect every butterfly wolf so that's what most of these trades consist of lmao

this is the other offer, obviously i'm really interested in the 2009 staff birthday bwolf but idk which is worth more in total

When it's a matter of art, take the one you prefer! However, I would personally take the one with the VR Bwolf and all the items. Those pets and items are individually worth more: it'll be easier for you to obtain the bwolves in the other offer individually, in my opinion.