The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Redbird]

is this a fair swap? Does the lion (I think it’s called light faced october?) have any special demand? I tried searching but I couldn’t find anything

That's fair. 09 lions tend to have good demand and can fetch more than their baseline price with patience, but that all depends on the person. There's nothing wrong with this trade if you're happy with it.

[☠puppy gutz!☠]

is this fair?

i never check threads 4 answers so if you answer here pls also pm me about whether it's fair or not!

repost bc there's also a 2nd trade now

[owl,]

is this a fair swap? Does the lion (I think it’s called light faced october?) have any special demand? I tried searching but I couldn’t find anything

That's fair. 09 lions tend to have good demand and can fetch more than their baseline price with patience, but that all depends on the person. There's nothing wrong with this trade if you're happy with it.

thank you so much for the help!! c:

[Redbird]

is this fair?

i never check threads 4 answers so if you answer here pls also pm me about whether it's fair or not!

repost bc there's also a 2nd trade now

It's not anyone's responsibility to go out of their way to PM you for help that you're seeking
There is no way to know whether a trade is fair when there are unknown rarities involved, however it's likely the first one will be unfair to them. I doubt the pink fox will be more than a common.

[mezzanine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165301&userid=980494&signature=ZH9RWylj8R3AcSPgr6_CLw


I need some help ASAP!!

Edit: I need help on this one too! trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165698&userid=980494&signature=VaHLIqveaNPO7diVqtMHTw

the top one is trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165301&userid=980494&signature=ZH9RWylj8R3AcSPgr6_CLw

[Redbird]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165301&userid=980494&signature=ZH9RWylj8R3AcSPgr6_CLw


I need some help ASAP!!

Edit: I need help on this one too! trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165698&userid=980494&signature=VaHLIqveaNPO7diVqtMHTw

the top one is trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165301&userid=980494&signature=ZH9RWylj8R3AcSPgr6_CLw

Second is unfair to you. One 2010 dog is more than enough for the horse, and I would remove the other two pets and replace with something closer in date for the rat.

[mezzanine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165301&userid=980494&signature=ZH9RWylj8R3AcSPgr6_CLw


I need some help ASAP!!

Edit: I need help on this one too! trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165698&userid=980494&signature=VaHLIqveaNPO7diVqtMHTw

the top one is trades/viewtrade.php?id=91165301&userid=980494&signature=ZH9RWylj8R3AcSPgr6_CLw

Second is unfair to you. One 2010 dog is more than enough for the horse, and I would remove the other two pets and replace with something closer in date for the rat.

Thank you very much!!!

Anyone else have advice for the first one?

[muffy]

is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91159721&userid=34599&signature=HifAErc525w0wgnCG8ey1g

[holodog]

Could I get a second opinion on these store pet trades? Thank you!
(1)
(2)
For 1, my partner is willing to add C$ (40 is their initial offer). For 2 my partner said in their message they're also willing to add to their side. I don't usually like trading down in date (except I am seeking/allowing trade downs for the deer offered in 2) so I'm a bit unsure about these!

[Storyboos]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91160041&userid=222130&signature=ZHslEfvRxenHAwjpscxWjw

Some 2012 rares, 3 2019 uncommons and 1 2019 rare
for
2 rare 2020 store pets, 3 current litter pps pets