I have continued to come back here year after year, even though I am a total lurker with few posts, because it is just so comfortable and cozy. It is one of the few art communities I know that feels safe. I love to passively collect things and chat with people in a noncommittal way. (I am looking at you, minimal forum games, aaaahhh)
I had been busy with college and starting my life and am not much of a social person in general, but it never seemed to me that the website was dying. Of course, as a person who doesn't trade adoptables, nor RP, nor reeeaaallly post at lot I don't know what I am talking about. But it seems that is what the site facilitates best--a community for animal lovers to hang out and create stuff and collect things and express themselves through that. Maybe bringing in new people means looking at what kids are doing now. Maybe it means altering the functions more for mobile so this can be played easier on a tablet. Maybe it means finding ways to combine media now with this. Maybe, it means leaning more into the niche that it might become--a place of nostalgia for people from a specific generation. The combo of RP & art seems really good here--I am excited about the follow features and how art works on here. There just isn't really a replacement for this experience that I am aware of.
I know some people have said too many contests can be too overwhelming, but as someone who works at a startup video game company, I disagree. If a person doesn't have time to participate in an event/contest, then they won't--but there will always be people who do have time and want to participate. Plus, the feeling that something is always happening is good for the site. Heck, I only really come here around halloween / summer / christmas to grab pets and leave, and browse art a bit. I always loved the trick or treat events that gets run (lights on / lights off). It seems a good idea would be to give people easy and constant opportunities to show off their art, writing, and pets, and reward them for it, and that would then bring in more people. Which I suppose is what is already happening, but more. :p Hmmmm.
Yeah, really tough thoughts here, because in many ways it does sound like the inevitable end of an era, but how can humankind really be done with forums like this? Am I already that old and out of touch ahahahaha
edit: it really might help to hire some form of game designer to figure out what to experiment with. People might be afraid of breaking the chicken smoothie tradition, but stuff like that could also create interesting buzz.