The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[fungi]

yeah this was unfair mistaked the red balloon dog for another balloon dog and I don't know how to delete this reply, sorry :(

[sunfloweer]

this

is this fair..? i would appreciate if you could reply asap as i do not want to leave them waiting any longer
thank you in advance

would the august pps for the cheshire cat be fair?

- sunfloweer ^^

I don't see any reason for the add on your side if I'm honest, but it is recent event stuff so not super significant if you don't mind letting them go (: As far as I know the Peach is more popular than the Foal but both are from the same Dec 18th and seem to go for the same (1-1.5 nons)
I've also done the same swap just over a year ago

I can try to answer your other question, though I don't know what either of them trade for but I think it would depend on who you ask. August PPS was always Very Rare and the Cheshire Cat was a set exclusive if I remember rightly. I have a feeling that the PPS may have higher demand (especially a true-date) but with the Cat being a reasonably old set exclusive (before C$ was trade-able) it's really hard for me to say.
I took a look on the VR & OMGSR Successful Trades Thread and the August PPS seems to go for around 3 Mid Advents worth upwards to september pets, and the Cheshire ranging from like one mid advent to a green sorbet??

Let's go with unfair to the Cheshire?

tysm! can i get a second opinion on the august pps for cheshire?

[Guest]

is this fair? tysm. im not the best with store pet worths

[EchothroughDarkness]

Are these fair??
Help ASAP
So which is the best??

1. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90364397&userid=410864&signature=8GkhBK3TtBKAalQXsYlGyg

2. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90383963&userid=410864&signature=j9qm1bBWKD4qU-iYJ2q-UQ + https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90403931&userid=410864&signature=zYwHHlnqDxml1nGMFsqWPg

3. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90554823&userid=410864&signature=4AqGDBFevmU4MQnEXWv43g

4. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90554847&userid=410864&signature=WN3_rhi4q2vbDGQQgwBEGg

5. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90599346&userid=410864&signature=AkFXrQVAqYaDym6s_Q02Bg

[coco-kitten]

hi! is this a fair offer for a BA? they valued it at 0.5 nons but im not sure if that's what it goes for

got some feedback on this one, but was wondering if I could get a second opinion.

[Queen~of~Crows]

Hello everyone! I'm running an auction for my joker dog, and seeing as the end date is sneaking up on me, I was wondering which trade would be best with demand and such? Thank you for any help in advance!


1.I like the grapes!
2.
Lovin the corgi pets!

3.
really loving the holly!

4.
I love the skull rat!

5.
love the ex lists! The target dog is one of my favorites!

[sketch..]

Just wanted to double check this bid as I am unsure of demand/value of the pets on their side.

trade

[shepherd's dog]

does this look fair?
i'm an older member and uncertain on trade values atm, but i know demand for store pets has gone up.

[RiЯ]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90604388&userid=58856&signature=0YSxW1szDRrjqik7glP7dQ

?

[blurry_cat1]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90449794&userid=994729&signature=POAL-LJFZ4g-uWSNPLfUmQ
hi! this is fair?
and this, please
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90590390&userid=994729&signature=WNy0tyqSZ3NNGWJJNkrIkA