The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ChrysanthemumT.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90129453&userid=635084&signature=05ab5HwJfkTxA3TscJlWQw

oh my please help, i really just need to know if its fair :0 thank you! theyve been waiting and i feel so bad

its been over a day now, please help!

Unfair to you, their pet would be around 2 09 rares and 1 10-13 rare

[nicole]

Is this fair? july lioness for white feb plus a few pets and items

And this?1 2012, 1 2017 store pet plus some others for white feb

The second trade is under, your side goes for 2MAs while they only have have 1 MA (2012 store pet), 1 09 rare (2017 store pet), and other stuff that doesn't really amount to the remaining 1MA they need to add for your white feb.

[Kabuski]

Is the ur strawberry cake hard to trade?
Just want some opinions on this, I feel like I’m over and that the pets (other than liontail) may be hard to trade

I personally value nons at 1,400

[elegance]

are either of these fair? any help would be so so appreciated!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90128392&userid=840275&signature=GCwfhUiP5KoPLALS8fz7FQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90125764&userid=840275&signature=7k7Su8ctQFFfy4RmDHcWPQ

or this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90132581&userid=840275&signature=6ifcnoVYINsRDtrC-5u2xw

[Viridian Dragonkoi]

Thoughts about this trade please?

I counted ~61 '09 rares(since most of the '08 ones were extended release), which is about half a non. The red toxic goes for .25-5 nons, and while there isn't much on the mint horse, it's generally going for around .5-1 non. Your side is .75-1 non, and theirs is .5-1 non.

Thank you so much.

Any other opinions?

[Kabuski]

are either of these fair? any help would be so so appreciated!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90128392&userid=840275&signature=GCwfhUiP5KoPLALS8fz7FQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90125764&userid=840275&signature=7k7Su8ctQFFfy4RmDHcWPQ

or this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90132581&userid=840275&signature=6ifcnoVYINsRDtrC-5u2xw

The scarves go for 2-3 ma’s each, but sometimes people will say a sorbets worth. Scarves are kinda hard to exactly value. Personally I got $500 for 1

So low end .5 high end 1 non (your side)
Their side is about .5-1 non (I’m having trouble finding info)

[Doglover879015]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90138184&userid=611416&signature=VMOmpaM3WZX1nfPatEzeaA Is this fair, I'm not sure about item worth?

[Shrimplybad]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90138184&userid=611416&signature=VMOmpaM3WZX1nfPatEzeaA Is this fair, I'm not sure about item worth?

Items are usually worth a common to uncommon of their year. The crow's from the 2020 carnival event, so this is fair ^^

[hexcore]

would this be fair?

I have no idea what the white icing is worth/goes for.

Thank you!

[crucifying.]

Asking again about this trade. Thank you in advance <3

on the other end. help please!