The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[A.M.Sleeper]

What would be fair for this trade? I'm mainly concerned about the very rare.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=90120307&userid=786786&signature=4G5-fN--1kDVGbhYnDIGbQ

[p&uline]

hehe i'm sorry for asking so much :c
but i'm just too bad with big trades and it's my first time trading away this one

trades/viewtrade.php?id=90112692&userid=953996&signature=p146zT-JEZMX4AlLJi4DVw

[Rayrayyyy]

Is this fair? galaxy bun and christmas snow cat for corgi set trades/viewtrade.php?id=90114024&userid=994998&signature=yc_WtQS2J942un5gmKudpA

if its not what could I add on my side to make it fair?
maybe should i add c$? how much if so?

[Horsesrule5000]

Is this fair?

[Guest]

I have an auction with no end date but here are some of my offers I would like to see if they're fair or not. Also i dont follow the list btw.
First one! I like it!
Not sure if it’s fair or not but I like the pets
I love the pets and most/all in true date!

Which guide do you use?

If you don't use any guides at all and trade by year and rarity: all trades are overpay on the other side.
Trade 1: the brown dog is a very rare from christmas 2008 (same event as your pet) so they would be a fair swap.
Trade 2: the other side is worth 1 2008VR + 1 2010 rare (valuing each 2019 store pet at 1 2010R)
Trade 3: they're offering 5 very rares from 2008 and more add so it would be some major overpay on the other side.

If you use the rarity guide: The angel advent turned VR on August 2010. There isn't a set value to fill the gaps so it's up to you to decide what fills the date gaps
Trade 1: the purple star bobtail turned VR on March 2011, in my opinion 1 2011 rare would be more than enough to fill this gap since it's pretty small.
Trade 2: The white sortic turned VR on January 2019. In my opinion this would be about fair since the gap is quite large.
Trade 3: the card dogs turned VR on January 2019, the mini husky turned VR on June 2011, the candycane bwolf turned VR on March 2011, the tan october moon turned VR on March 2013, the black dutch bun and the store pet have been VR since release so it's a massive overpay on the other side. the other person was probably using the rares list to make this offer, it would be nice to let them know that you don't use it!

[Horsesrule5000]

Is this fair? galaxy bun and christmas snow cat for corgi set trades/viewtrade.php?id=90114024&userid=994998&signature=yc_WtQS2J942un5gmKudpA

if its not what could I add on my side to make it fair?
maybe should i add c$? how much if so?

Valuing their side at:
Corgi = 115 × 4 = 460c$

Your side at:
Sitting cat = 55c$
Bun = 145c$
You could add 260c$ to make this fair OR 5 09 rares

[moon child]

is this fair both rarity and demand wise? i’m not sure if the non jewelled liontail has good demand. also how many nons is it worth?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=90114218&userid=774839&signature=cG8gjXiaMtYVv-OtEXBTEg

[Kamiluna]

Help?


Help please I've been asking since page 630(ish)

[mochahearts]

I have an auction with no end date but here are some of my offers I would like to see if they're fair or not. Also i dont follow the list btw.
First one! I like it!
Not sure if it’s fair or not but I like the pets
I love the pets and most/all in true date!

Which guide do you use?

If you don't use any guides at all and trade by year and rarity: all trades are overpay on the other side.
Trade 1: the brown dog is a very rare from christmas 2008 (same event as your pet) so they would be a fair swap.
Trade 2: the other side is worth 1 2008VR + 1 2010 rare (valuing each 2019 store pet at 1 2010R)
Trade 3: they're offering 5 very rares from 2008 and more add so it would be some major overpay on the other side.

If you use the rarity guide: The angel advent turned VR on August 2010. There isn't a set value to fill the gaps so it's up to you to decide what fills the date gaps
Trade 1: the purple star bobtail turned VR on March 2011, in my opinion 1 2011 rare would be more than enough to fill this gap since it's pretty small.
Trade 2: The white sortic turned VR on January 2019. In my opinion this would be about fair since the gap is quite large.
Trade 3: the card dogs turned VR on January 2019, the mini husky turned VR on June 2011, the candycane bwolf turned VR on March 2011, the tan october moon turned VR on March 2013, the black dutch bun and the store pet have been VR since release so it's a massive overpay on the other side. the other person was probably using the rares list to make this offer, it would be nice to let them know that you don't use it!

Thank you so much! I'm still trying to get around my rares/lists since im a comes back player, but now knowing about this, ill go by the list for the sake of me trying to get more comfortable with everything. Thank you.

[Shy]

1 no they are giving to much

2 i bit better than 1 but its still a no

3 is the same