The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[adderblade]

Hello~!

Could anyone please tell me if this trade is fair at all?

Any help is appreciated! Thank you!

Sadly, no. Not counting any demand, each store pet is worth one '10 rare. They have 2 '10 rares and 2 '11 rares.

Your side counts up to one '08 rare, and there's is 1 '09 rare and 1 '10 rare.

[suspicious]

is this fair?

thanksss

also this one thanksss

ah can i get a second opinion pleasee thanks

[Faeyre]

is this fair?

[SpookyMerlin]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89782031&userid=998263&signature=6ik7oiaDiqWBGSDGZQU52Q Is this fair? Bc I really really want to accept it

[suspicious]

ignore this

[SpookyMerlin]

Oml Ima bout to cry! They’re so nice!!! <3

[spirited away]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89768736&userid=813435&signature=FStSIm2q_WrXMPWx0rwZSg
been asking for a while please help

[VNKP]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89784238&userid=985924&signature=Fbj8gt0tS6ArgRIo7y9QIw

If I have calculated correctly they have what is a 2016 rare plus an uncommon on their side? And if they do have a 2016 rare is that fair for my 3 rares from this year or are they overpaying ?

[musicgurl333]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89784238&userid=985924&signature=Fbj8gt0tS6ArgRIo7y9QIw

If I have calculated correctly they have what is a 2016 rare plus an uncommon on their side? And if they do have a 2016 rare is that fair for my 3 rares from this year or are they overpaying ?

It depends on how you value the gap between years, and also rares/uncommons/commons. Personally, I go by 2VC=1 common and 3 commons =1 rare. Their side adds up to just over 2 ‘16 uncommons, so to me that doesn’t equal a ‘16 rare. As far as years, if you follow the doubling rule, the 1 ‘16 uncommon=2 ‘17 uncommons =4 ‘18 uncommons=8 ‘19 uncommons =16 ‘20 uncommons, which equals about 4-5 ‘20 rares. So it would be about overpay on their side. Personally though, I wouldn’t accept if it was me. I don’t agree with doubling pet values, and I think you could do better.

[VNKP]

Okay thank you! : )