The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[♡Raven114♡]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780490&userid=991127&signature=ZkqHr0oitlHIVvqH2d-2tA


please help, he says that the leopard plushie goes for an 09 very rare, is this true? not great with items, thanks in advance

The leopard plushie is from 2009, in the valentines section, and I believe most '09s are rare (I dont think any are uncommon or below, correct me if wrong) so maybe thats what they are going for. Just letting you know if you didn't, but I don't have any advice to offer for this trade ^^;

thank you so much for the help, any second opinions?

[uro]

Are these fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89760519&userid=885564&signature=df8lplJEPtHIcJNTzhVQ1w
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89742645&userid=885564&signature=dO5KIOlQiFnxV1UJ13ZtQw

not sure about the first one, but the second one is definitely unfair to you. the blonde horsehair wig has a lot of demand and is said to be worth an 09 rare in the item worth thread, that item alone should swap with their 09 staff dog. the rest of the items/pet is extreme overpay on your part.

[Biparo]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780490&userid=991127&signature=ZkqHr0oitlHIVvqH2d-2tA


please help, he says that the leopard plushie goes for an 09 very rare, is this true? not great with items, thanks in advance

The leopard plushie is from 2009, in the valentines section, and I believe most '09s are rare (I dont think any are uncommon or below, correct me if wrong) so maybe thats what they are going for. Just letting you know if you didn't, but I don't have any advice to offer for this trade ^^;

thank you so much for the help, any second opinions?

I think this is fair/overpay on your partners side. This seems like decent deal.

[CloudedJasper]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89641170&userid=856554&signature=5DijvA4hKTeLCgm-ujgM4w

[adderblade]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89641170&userid=856554&signature=5DijvA4hKTeLCgm-ujgM4w

In total, you have four '10 rare pets and an '10 uncommon. Using the 2:1 rule, two '09 rares plus the uncommon. The warrior cat is around 2 '09 rares, so you are overpaying by a bit, but warrior cat demand can kinda counter that, though still sorta overpaying. I would leave this trade though, if you really want the warrior and can spare the extra uncommon :) Please get a second opinion!

[Biparo]

how's this?

Each of the dogs is worth a '10 rare, There side doesn't even come close to that.

[adderblade]

how's this?

If my calculations are correct, one of your storepets is overpay ^^;
Please get a second opinion, I could've gotten that wrong :>

[aniuk]

how's this?

unfair to you.
2020 store pets are valued at a late '10 rare each(** some value them at an early '11, but late '10 is most common)
here's their offer broken down by the 2:1 rule:
10 '14 rares
5 '13 rares
2 '12 rares and 1 '13 rare
1 '11 rare and 1 '13 rare
two rares = one rare of the previous year

so, i agree with the given opinions! their side isn't even worth one of your pets.

[adderblade]

@retro
No problem ^^

[MsCanadian]

Hello~!

Could anyone please tell me if this trade is fair at all?

Any help is appreciated! Thank you!