The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[grey matter]

can someone help judge this?

[owl,]

Is this fair? I’m not really sure about the rarity and demand of store pets...thank you so much!! c:

feel free to get second opinions as im not great with demand c:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89638893&userid=990178&signature=CSCbaYf8c6Vk4ar659W1Fg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89703155&userid=990178&signature=Q8P9svtVSztEYMLbc8OtsA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89621258&userid=990178&signature=UzvTVTat-pzVCwuYMmqHFg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89610196&userid=990178&signature=RVQR6htGQkGCXDP41kd5gw

I need help with my auction. Any help is apriciated. Thanks in advance.

1: doesnt seem fair at all, everything is recent and none of the items are even rare.
2: the math adds up to being fair/ over pay if you se the 2:1 ratio but im honestly not sure
3: that seems fair as well with one 10 rare as overpay
4: seems like theres too many very commons for that to add up to being fair for you

Is this fair to the other person?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89777261&userid=992747&signature=hK2PtX_tfgqTO9J3wc_erg

seems unfair to them as that horse is a march 2010 rare, so using the 3 month rule it might be worth 2 rare 10 rats since theirs are december pets

is this fair? im pretty sure theyre overpaying

they are indeed over paying, very unfair to them by a 09 rare and 10 very rare!

Is This Fair/Would You Do This?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89773334&userid=919360&signature=__ahm2xDAZ3MDVTJD9sikw

Thank You So Much For Whoever Helps Me Out! (:

seems unfair to them by the very rare, true date pets and rerelease pets are worth the same. plus 16 store pets are worth early 10 rares!

Hi, is this a better trade?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89777209&userid=166678&signature=yWHmCzrY397dGffsHqiOng
Thank you!

by 2:1 ratio this seems unfair to you as 4 2017 rares = 1 2013 uc and the 16 rare = a 13 vc

please help i dont want to keep them waiting

okay so 17 store pets are worth late 10 rares, so id say more on the end of being unfair to you, im sorry about that!

can someone help judge this?

ive heard 19 store pets are worth mid to late 2010 rares so by that logic its not fair to you at all

[ellyenchanted]

this trade?

[♡April~lynn♡]

can someone help judge this?

ive heard 19 store pets are worth mid to late 2010 rares so by that logic its not fair to you at all

[/quote]
It's actually fair/overpay on other persons side 1 2017 store pet+ a 2019 store pet adds up to about a early 2017/late 2016 store pet and based on demand also the rare makes it about fair

[suspicious]

is this fair?

thanksss

[Kabuski]

Aren't the rats hard to trade for a sorb? Along with the rainbow horse?

[spirited away]

fair?

[SpookyMerlin]

Hi! I wanted to know if this was fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780043&userid=998263&signature=UtNzoIFDpLHCFQJPJ9xuLw I’m new to this site so I’m not really good with dates or anything :3

[wlw]

Hi! I wanted to know if this was fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=89780043&userid=998263&signature=UtNzoIFDpLHCFQJPJ9xuLw I’m new to this site so I’m not really good with dates or anything :3

its very unfair to you, a 2020 rare is only equal to a 2019 uncommon, so it doesnt fill the gap left by the 2014 uncommon :-)

[SpookyMerlin]

Okie dokies Tysm!