The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pg53294]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89665754&userid=696545&signature=JpDiggmnq-NEOhrxdmy5Cw Can someone please help me tell if this is fair or not?

[samiam52900]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=89699855&userid=993343&signature=lbjfAG-VnUpSvCxb2Q1F-w
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=89699723&userid=993343&signature=UUV2rmdwf1_7J-sZriPt4Q
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=89699725&userid=993343&signature=9cwvMgplqDp0nE8zk_eB6g
4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=89699872&userid=993343&signature=rZV0GCeyVBlsGfXtUpCm7A
5. trades/viewtrade.php?id=89699893&userid=993343&signature=pFMFYYu1Ap86uTQofk7jFA
are these okay? Which is the best and would you take it if you were my side?
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=89703265&userid=993343&signature=264YadbMISnxvdwypi0vuw
sam
please help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89724904&userid=993343&signature=GYBqemIuCwUpQDD69v-CEQ i know this is fare, but would you take it? does this puppy have that high demand?

[Catdoof]

Little unsure on this one - wanted another opinion

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89729458&userid=652185&signature=sFfWMStDr-GZNE5Eri7xXQ

[jutdwae]

Little unsure on this one - wanted another opinion

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89729458&userid=652185&signature=sFfWMStDr-GZNE5Eri7xXQ

OOf your overpaying by a lot. 4 2020 rares would be worth 2 2019 rares, or 1 2018 rare, OR a 2020 storept possibly depending on how much you value each 2020 rare (I personally value 1 2020 rare at 3 c$)

[VNKP]

Help with this?
Thank you!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89716644&userid=985924&signature=U6JBBWyvQxE_qDDHVbllkA

[Telemel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89729511&userid=907285&signature=qIxiZWdhdU8i3w20Sy-Yng

Is this fair?

[douxvamp_]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89729510&userid=994230&signature=ZYvA1PM4VreEq9grSutxXA

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89703395&userid=994230&signature=LG83b7yBHvjY01Wf14X-9g

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89693704&userid=994230&signature=-HSdImP7WrWslGIzNu9pJg

[musicgurl333]

Little unsure on this one - wanted another opinion

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89729458&userid=652185&signature=sFfWMStDr-GZNE5Eri7xXQ

OOf your overpaying by a lot. 4 2020 rares would be worth 2 2019 rares, or 1 2018 rare, OR a 2020 storept possibly depending on how much you value each 2020 rare (I personally value 1 2020 rare at 3 c$)

I do agree that going by the rule where pet values double yearly, their side equals an ‘18 rare, and you would be overpaying. However, I personally don’t think it seems like a completely unreasonable trade. You could probably add another ‘20 rare or two to their side, but realistically I doubt you’d be able to get much more than that.

I do disagree that 4 ‘20 rares equals a store pet. Valuing a ‘20 rare at 3C$ each, 4 would only be 12C$. Even if you get the set discount a store pet is about 15C$, which would be 5 ‘20 rares. To get to the full 20C$ value you’d need 7 ‘20 rares. Though I think you’d have a hard time finding someone to trade one for that.

Help with this?
Thank you!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=89716644&userid=985924&signature=U6JBBWyvQxE_qDDHVbllkA

It looks a little unfair to you, depending on how you value rares to uncommons, as well as the gap between years. Personally, I valued each rare on your side as 2 ‘19 uncommons, and I valued 2 ‘20 uncommons as 1 ‘19 uncommon. I also valued an uncommon as 3 commons. (Hopefully that’s not too confusing.)

Doing it that way, I got about 11 ‘19 uncommons worth on your side, and about 8 1/2 on their side. Also worth noting, event pets tend to have slightly higher demand.

[aniuk]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89729510&userid=994230&signature=ZYvA1PM4VreEq9grSutxXA

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89703395&userid=994230&signature=LG83b7yBHvjY01Wf14X-9g

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89693704&userid=994230&signature=-HSdImP7WrWslGIzNu9pJg

trade 1:
this was very unfair to them. 2020 store pets are not worth nearly as much as '16 store pets. '20 store pets are worth a late '10 rare, while '16 stores are worth an '09 rare. you would have needed to add a '10 rare, not a 2019 common.

trade 2:
same as the first trade, you still aren't adding enough to make up for the gap.

trade 3:
one '15 common = 2 '16 common = 4 '17 common
this trade is unfair to you, you're overpaying.

feel free to get more advice!

[Telemel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89729511&userid=907285&signature=qIxiZWdhdU8i3w20Sy-Yng

Is this fair?