The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sunfloweer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88338602&userid=956725&signature=aXECiO_LpFpNgFOLNIqZHQ

is this fair? what is the cheshire worth? do you know any successful trades for it?
- sunfloweer ^^

also this :)

the first link wasnt working so here it is again trades/viewtrade.php?id=88338602&userid=956725&signature=aXECiO_LpFpNgFOLNIqZHQ

[Redbird]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88107110&userid=27822&signature=Rq2qGkLVRmfemTGa2G5j9Q

Thoughts on this? 2011 Elf costume pieces worth.

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88345045&userid=900297&signature=VODo-szlW9bw3H8HYmHpYw


I don’t like rats but I guess it’s sorta fair because of the date, rats are very low demand though, so I’m not sure, help please

Rarity wise it’s unfair to them. Both your cat and their rat are 2010 Rares. Demand wise it’s ultimately up to you, I think the bunnies make this trade more fair personally. I’d take this.

[snowdrake]

is this a good offer?

I feel like I might be overpaying with all those high demand rares. I value warriors at 3 09 rares and the card dogs at a tier 1 advent+

edit: just counted it up and it would be a bit over 100 09 rares using the way I value my pets. is that fair for a sorbet?

[Founderr18]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88345852&userid=989106&signature=vVhxSzSTv18nhfj6Fh9sfg

is this fair? i value the ur butterbun at a solid non since ive had a few before and they are relatively easy to trade off. what would have to be added or removed to be fair to this? demand included

[phxyvi]

is this a good offer?

I feel like I might be overpaying with all those high demand rares. I value warriors at 3 09 rares and the card dogs at a tier 1 advent+

I counted the warriors at 1 09 because I do not see them getting 3 consistently, and 08 vrs at 2 09s+2010, and still got around 76 09s. Which is around fair imo valuing a sorb at 65-75 09s, You are indeed overpaying if you value them at 3, though.

[Shrimplybad]

Thoughts on these two? Are the bengal and foal similar demand-wise? Thank you!!! :)

[DarknessANDLight]

Thoughts on these two? Are the bengal and foal similar demand-wise? Thank you!!!

I wouldn't take the first one, The Bengal is 1-1.5 while I haven't seen the foal go for more than 1, I recently had a foal and couldn't even swap for a non with significant add on my side, I would keep the Bengal

I wouldn't take the other one either as the peas are .5-.75 of a non usually .5, and the c$ is a low main worth, the other pets don't make a huge difference to the value of there side even if you valued the peas at .75 the trade is still unfair to you

[Kabuski]

1
2

Both are red rose trades !
Idk what the demand is like for the rat, im sure it's not very good, but what is it worth.
Also, red toxics?

[Kabuski]

1
2

Both are red rose trades !
Idk what the demand is like for the rat, im sure it's not very good, but what is it worth.
Also, red toxics?