The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sunfloweer]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88338602&userid=956725&signature=aXECiO_LpFpNgFOLNIqZHQ

is this fair? what is the cheshire worth? do you know any successful trades for it?
- sunfloweer ^^

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88343143&userid=993343&signature=JjHNTn2_HYcVogRHNCErMA hi! should i take this? i was told that staff dogs are worth more? would you guys take this?

The 2008 dog is worth an early '09 VR + a late '10 rare, so this trade is unfair to them. The staff pets, which only have normal demand, add up to a late '09 VR and the butterwolves aren't enough to close the gap.

I also agree with this. Remember bulk doesn’t necessarily make a trade fair.

[Shrimplybad]

I can't find the items in the archive so I'm not sure how much theyre worth :') Would this be fair? Thanks in advance! :)

[Rbpuppy]

I can't find the items in the archive so I'm not sure how much theyre worth :') Would this be fair? Thanks in advance!

The wings alone are from the 2011 Medieval Summer Event so this is very unfair to them.

[Founderr18]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88341521&userid=989106&signature=uZJWyytvhV870CFkhzPEeQ

hows this? im unsure.

[DisneyLuv]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88341521&userid=989106&signature=uZJWyytvhV870CFkhzPEeQ

hows this? im unsure.

The pineapple and the Butterbun combined are at least 2 nons, and sometimes the pineapple can go for another .5 nons. So your side is 2-2.5 nons plus a small add with the store pet. Their side only scratches up to nearly 1.5 nons. This wouldn’t be fair to you.

[Shrimplybad]

I feel bad comin back so soon but I just got these two trades:
x
x
They'd both be under, right?

[a b c d e]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88343862&userid=780618&signature=_Evb5uGLBkrdYuRHrvY0rQ
I'd appreciate any help! abcde

[Draconica2014]

trade 1
items

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88343862&userid=780618&signature=_Evb5uGLBkrdYuRHrvY0rQ
I'd appreciate any help! abcde

Unfair to them. The rerelease dog is from ‘09. Going by the most commonly used values, the recent store pet equals a ‘10 rare (though I personally value them higher), and that and the ‘10 rereleased horse add up to another ‘09 rare. VR pets are typically considered worth 2 rares of the same year.

I believe it would be about fair if you took everything off their side except 1 ‘13 uncommon (for for your commons), 1 ‘20 common (for your two ‘20 VC), and the draft, ‘09 dog, and store pet (for your butterfly wolf). Feel free to get a second opinion though.