The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[gunthyr]

is this fair to me?

the 2015 rare is worth a 2009 rare but could possibly fetch more because of demand. the trade is fair

[All Hallows Eve]

Should I trade my 2 Rare 2009 Warrior Cats
for their VR 2009 Rainbow Dog?

I think I'll take it, but Warrior cats are so hard to get.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88294172&userid=708529&signature=ixXLWlXfBrBzPQH3JkgFbA

[Domino Tricks]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88331269&userid=972572&signature=DjjMX_UmpfDvgOFgI-7xJg

Is this fair? I wasn't sure how much to ask for.

My 52 to their 13/ that's my 4 to their 1

EDIT:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88331304&userid=972572&signature=JHfK_a7buOngsxlRf0DsIA
They edited that trade, now is their 22 to my 66

[Minibug ♡]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88331269

Is this fair? I wasn't sure how much to ask for.

My 52 to their 13/ that's my 4 to their 1

wrong link, use the one at the bottom of the trade page

[gunthyr]

is this a good offer for my green toxic, or can i get better? im only skeptical because the user im trading with labelled their red toxic at 0.5 nons
i know their side adds up to a teeny bit over 4 mid advents which is fair for 0.25 nons, but can a green toxic get 0.5 non's worth?

[Demonking Urizen]

is this a good offer for my green toxic, or can i get better? im only skeptical because the user im trading with labelled their red toxic at 0.5 nons

Green and Red usually trade for 0.25 Nons, which is roughly 3 - 4 mid advents.
Only Yellow, Blue and rarely Purple seem to fetch 0.5 Nons.
So this trade looks fine.

[gunthyr]

is this a good offer for my green toxic, or can i get better? im only skeptical because the user im trading with labelled their red toxic at 0.5 nons

Green and Red usually trade for 0.25 Nons, which is roughly 3 - 4 mid advents.
Only Yellow, Blue and rarely Purple seem to fetch 0.5 Nons.
So this trade looks fine.

okay; thank you! <3

[Sarcastic Hawke]

Would this be considered fair? I'm the side w/the PPS Gryphon store pet.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88324098&userid=35419&signature=WBYbgvbBk1iF5OqmCCjvJA

[Dollteeths]

Would this be considered fair? I'm the side w/the PPS Gryphon store pet.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88324098&userid=35419&signature=WBYbgvbBk1iF5OqmCCjvJA

i believe this is fair (depeneding on the person) but ive also
received 2-3 09' rares for mine,,, so I'm not fully sure..
i'd get a second opinion.

[RenSleep]

This