The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[snowdrake]

is this a good deal?

[Black.Wings]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88317812&userid=878037&signature=s30cj6cYRlxsMrw0B36fIQ

My math tells me this is unfair to the C$. a 12' uncommon is worth 7C$ a 13' uncommon is worth 6C$ a 14' common is worth 2.5C$ so you're looking at about 18C$ worth.

[Horsesrule5000]

How many c$ would make this fair?

[rainfall;]

how's this?
i'm not sure if i should be valuing the rat at its list placement (250c$, tier 8) since it became an OMGSR

[hexcore]

is this fair? I really love all the store pets and the skunk is a dreamie of mine. Thanks in advance! (please let me know ASAP. i don't want to keep them waiting. ❤)

Please reply. I really don't want to keep them wating! Thank you!

[RenSleep]

Are these fair

[Draconica2014]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88317812&userid=878037&signature=s30cj6cYRlxsMrw0B36fIQ

[Black.Wings]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88317812&userid=878037&signature=s30cj6cYRlxsMrw0B36fIQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88321524&userid=878037&signature=SNjpbjRdR7wnH-QPjpufZg

very slightly unfair to the top. a 2018 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare, this is an early 10' rare

[Black.Wings]

Are these fair

First two I dont know but the third is debatable, a 19' uncommon is worth about 1C$ so any demand or etc is up to the user.

[Kabuski]

Are these fair

1. Going by the pets alone, no. They would be fair for maybe 2016 common. The items I believe were all free, other than the ball of yarn. Really it's just your preference on the items and how you'd personally value them, other than the plushie none of them have special demand. Unfair to you.

2. Those animal tokens are from a recent event within the past few years, so they don't really have much worth. 2014's are a fair swap, but staff pets do have special demand, that's that varies person to person. Whether you want to give that me unknown rarities is up to you. Other than thatm unfair to you.

3. I can't help sowwy