The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[venti]

Is this fair??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88292827&userid=410864&signature=obPM7EfgoisHluMNxZFh0w

As far as I know, your pet is only worth 4 ‘09 rares. Their overpay is pretty significant. The alien dog is worth 1 MA, which is 7-8 ‘09 rares, plus the 2012 VR with some demand of its own. It’s up to you on what to do, but I’d led them know what they’re doing.

THANK YOU OML I NEVER KNEW I WAS OVERPAYING CAUSE YEA ໒( ●ᴥ ●)ʋ

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88292827&userid=410864&signature=obPM7EfgoisHluMNxZFh0w

As far as I know, your pet is only worth 4 ‘09 rares. Their overpay is pretty significant. The alien dog is worth 1 MA, which is 7-8 ‘09 rares, plus the 2012 VR with some demand of its own. It’s up to you on what to do, but I’d led them know what they’re doing.

Another opinion

[Genba]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88292768&userid=320360&signature=k230yZ8f6G7iFs-2Ke1pPw

I don't really know what the basilisks are valued at

The basilisks are valued at 1.5 MA’s each. But they are asking for overpay. The fox is worth around 1.5 nons, and you only need the sorbet and the GWJ to meet that value. The GWJ being worth 1 non and the sorb being worth a sorb. I’d edit and take off the basilisks.

Thanks!!

[Rhiley]

Hi! Can anyone give me any ideas about this trade? Thank you!

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88292827&userid=410864&signature=obPM7EfgoisHluMNxZFh0w

As far as I know, your pet is only worth 4 ‘09 rares. Their overpay is pretty significant. The alien dog is worth 1 MA, which is 7-8 ‘09 rares, plus the 2012 VR with some demand of its own. It’s up to you on what to do, but I’d led them know what they’re doing.

Another opinion

[EchothroughDarkness]

Can I have this checked?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88293803&userid=410864&signature=LJcuEEc4B4jYLEYPUACSIw

[woes]

Really need help with this one, I’m clueless.

[Demonking Urizen]

Really need help with this one, I’m clueless.

Slightly unfair to them as the Coontail is going for 1.5 - 2 Non but tends to fetch the lower end and your side adds up to a bit more than 1.25 Non (Sorb = 0.5, Peas = 0.5 and Green Tox = 0.25)

Is this fair??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88292827&userid=410864&signature=obPM7EfgoisHluMNxZFh0w

As far as I know, your pet is only worth 4 ‘09 rares. Their overpay is pretty significant. The alien dog is worth 1 MA, which is 7-8 ‘09 rares, plus the 2012 VR with some demand of its own. It’s up to you on what to do, but I’d led them know what they’re doing.

Another opinion

Unfair to them. The VR has had an extended release and is worth 4 '09 rares with patience but usually fetches only 2 '09 rares. Their side is worth 8 '09 rares, the horse doesn't have any significant demand.

[Horsesrule5000]

Is this fair?

Their side adds up to roughly 6.5 mid advents (considered that the full sketchi alicorn set can go for a mid advent) so this is fair as the Sorb goes for 6-7 mid advents.

How many MA's does the WWA go for then?

[venti]

Am I going under for this trade? Should I add more?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88289946&userid=878040&signature=mJDFwcPXJM-jAYUpV89Cww

Yes. Warriors seem to go to 2 2009 rares which equals to 4 2010 rares.