The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Horsesrule5000]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=88139561&userid=613733&signature=HO26S67l27iGVTE6KkTOBQ

[♥Nikoleta♥]

Can anyone please help me? It's too bulk, I have no idea
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88151804&userid=399960&signature=rK19NRl8vmxocKiBy4U9LA

[Demonking Urizen]

Can anyone please help me? It's too bulk, I have no idea
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=88151804&userid=399960&signature=rK19NRl8vmxocKiBy4U9LA

Unfair to you. the first four pets on their side are already overpay for your rares.

[Reki.]

Are they asking a bit much?

If anything, your side would be underpay. The hyena VR has good demand, and can go for 3 ‘09 rares instead of 2. The tiger store pet can easily go for 1-2 ‘09 rares due to demand as well. Since the pets they want from you add up to only 3 ‘09 rares, around 2 more might be needed to close that gap. But it’s up to you on whether you want to adjust It <3

Could I get one more opinion please? I have gotten multiple advice saying its unfair to me, so now I am so unsure.

[Demonking Urizen]

Are they asking a bit much?

If anything, your side would be underpay. The hyena VR has good demand, and can go for 3 ‘09 rares instead of 2. The tiger store pet can easily go for 1-2 ‘09 rares due to demand as well. Since the pets they want from you add up to only 3 ‘09 rares, around 2 more might be needed to close that gap. But it’s up to you on whether you want to adjust It <3

Could I get one more opinion please? I have gotten multiple advice saying its unfair to me, so now I am so unsure.

It is unfair to you. The 2012 rare is not needed and they need to add another '16 uncommon on their side to make it fair.

[~mysticwolf~]

Just wanted to double check this was fair ^-^
Sunjewel for bulk

I believe it was just wanted to double check ^-^
Ur galaxy + blood dog = 1.5 nons
Zodiac set = 0.5 nons
Ur Aussie = 1 non
+ The additional stores

I think I added it up about right but this is my first time doing a big list trade over 1.5 nons so wanted to double check ^-^

[greenfinch]

thoughts on...
this and this?
thanks!

[phxyvi]

If anything, your side would be underpay. The hyena VR has good demand, and can go for 3 ‘09 rares instead of 2. The tiger store pet can easily go for 1-2 ‘09 rares due to demand as well. Since the pets they want from you add up to only 3 ‘09 rares, around 2 more might be needed to close that gap. But it’s up to you on whether you want to adjust It <3

Could I get one more opinion please? I have gotten multiple advice saying its unfair to me, so now I am so unsure.

Maybe you’re seeing pets I don’t, but I would agree with Disney. This is a good offer. I sincerely doubt you’d get another one for your pets.
Furthermore, if you’ve gotten the advice you need then perhaps this is not the place for you. Or you could state that in your initial message ^^

If anything, your side would be underpay. The hyena VR has good demand, and can go for 3 ‘09 rares instead of 2. The tiger store pet can easily go for 1-2 ‘09 rares due to demand as well. Since the pets they want from you add up to only 3 ‘09 rares, around 2 more might be needed to close that gap. But it’s up to you on whether you want to adjust It <3

Could I get one more opinion please? I have gotten multiple advice saying its unfair to me, so now I am so unsure.

It is unfair to you. The 2012 rare is not needed and they need to add another '16 uncommon on their side to make it fair.

That might be true but both the storepet and the dog go for overpay rather easily on the other’s side. Where was the horses will likely go for underpay (as in being sold for the price of 2010s in c$ shops, traded for half value, etc?)

Just wanted to double check this was fair ^-^
Sunjewel for bulk

I believe it was just wanted to double check ^-^
Ur galaxy + blood dog = 1.5 nons
Zodiac set = 0.5 nons
Ur Aussie = 1 non
+ The additional stores

I think I added it up about right but this is my first time doing a big list trade over 1.5 nons so wanted to double check ^-^

Unless they plan on selling them for c$ I wouldn’t have in a million years even considered for a single millisecond in time valuing the zodiac set at a sorbet as it doesn’t consistently get that in pets. I would have never advised the sunjewel accepting that. You got a good deal though I would be incredibly wary of sharing the trade around

[Shrimplybad]

Thoughts? Thanks for your time ^^

----

Edit: Got a second one for my items. Odd! Still don't understand item values though :')

[malicemizer]

I have a few offers for my tree, not sure which to accept. Any help? Kinda looking for other stuff but, just seeing which trade is best for me.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88151416&userid=993206&signature=YefZluecrXEpH3QpCb2Z3g

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88151401&userid=993206&signature=7HbXN6jJb1GgseRRuDmwHA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=88151357

help
^^??