The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dounut4life]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87786382&userid=990277&signature=yGzxn5VxhsakicaZ8CyDAg

need FAST HELP PLEASE

Extremely unfair to you, the first bunch of pets are already enough for the 2010 dog, going by the 2:1 rule.

[VashTheStampede]

Got another bid for my UR Lion that I'm having trouble calculating. Would love any help please ♡ what would you all value their side at non-wise?

[VashTheStampede]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87784886&userid=990277&signature=yEiBqAZElpMlqLABBDu0BQ

help me please and fast :(

A '16 R goes for about 2-4 C$. The BW is a fair swap for one of them. You're just slightly over with the 5 C$, but I personally wouldnt mind it because dragons have a somewhat steady demand. I'd say this trade is fair

Edit: my bad. '16 R goes for 6-8 C$. I had looked at an older C$ worth thread by mistake

[mitochondria.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87745400&userid=753287&signature=FKeEWG6A1MKJngWLvUlq1w

I'm not very good at trading, any advice on this one? fast help preferred but not necessary /:

[spirit • daydream]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87784886&userid=990277&signature=yEiBqAZElpMlqLABBDu0BQ

help me please and fast

A '16 R goes for about 2-4 C$. The BW is a fair swap for one of them. You're just slightly over with the 5 C$, but I personally wouldnt mind it because dragons have a somewhat steady demand. I'd say this trade is fair

A 2016 rare goes for about 6-8 C$ according to the pets worth thread

[♥ꜱᴋʀ1ᴍᴘᴢ♥]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87786651&userid=707713&signature=dQSDGXCQuv5kSP4jSMwIcQ

again seeking help,

[hellotheworld]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87786651&userid=707713&signature=dQSDGXCQuv5kSP4jSMwIcQ

again seeking help,

[frogpeex]

Is this a fair trade? I need help ASAP.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87784663&userid=968168&signature=q6hBmhHrORK5PeQbbS8yfw

[faygeleh]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87745400&userid=753287&signature=FKeEWG6A1MKJngWLvUlq1w

I'm not very good at trading, any advice on this one? fast help preferred but not necessary /:

recent store pets are valued 2010 rares, that is a 2018 store, that would be worth a 2009 rare.

this isn't true, please be careful with the advice you give. the value of a store pet is based roughly on its c$ worth. 2018-2020 store pets are all worth 2010 rares. a 2018 store pet is worth an early 2010 rare, a 2019 store pet is worth a mid 2010 rare, and a 2020 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare. their dog is from february 2010, so its perfectly fair.



here's a quick guide for general reference, based on rarity alone:
currently in-store 2020 store pets = early 2011 rare/late or low demand 2010 rare
2020 store pet = late 2010 rare
2019 store pet = mid 2010 rare
2018 store pet = early 2010 rare
2017 store pet = late '09 rare
2016 store pet = mid '09 rare
2015 store pet = early '09 rare
2014 store pet = 2 '09 rares
2013 store pet = 3-4 '09 rares
2012 store pets are currently going for mid advent list pets, and a full set is going for a mid september pet
2011 store pets are going for mid september pets, and a full set could go for a low/mid mainlist
2010 and back are already on the list and go anywhere from a sorb to several nons depending on the year

[VashTheStampede]

Which would you guys say is better?

Bid 1
Bid 2 (from the same person as bid 1, just trying to figure out which one is better)

Bid 3