The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Supreme]

Can you guys help me with these two trades?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87694269&userid=702384&signature=7lyiUNWclJmsjrtpTAhf2w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=80263917&userid=702384&signature=W2gnC0yd9FvVj5SNf_hTIA

[Lighinz]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724626&userid=701412&signature=7YLromKysn6uOfIPqEhicQ

Would really appreciate some help with this trade!

[faygeleh]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87719921&userid=786321&signature=AlIvgADA-aYCq8BUCgDHAQ

Is this fair? I can't really tell anymore since I haven't played for a while. Thank you so much in advance!!

unfair to you, your '09 vr alone would be overpay for everything on their side-- the '09 vr on its own is worth 2 '09 rares, their whole side is barely worth 1.75 '09 rares.

Help? I think they're fair rarity wise but I'm wondering if it's fair demand wise.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724494&userid=963983&signature=ner47a28Bn0jc6147_bDVA

i agree that its fair rarity wise, but demand wise the african wild dog is definitely better-- although not by much. i personally think its fine as it is, but you really want to fill the small demand gap i'm sure a couple older uncommons on their side would be plenty.

[Baelixx]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87704129&userid=489914&signature=NShiEaI9d2XyYCNnyHUpOg
literally haven't done trades in so long and now I'm just realizing how outdated I am on all of this. Any help is greatly appreciated :3 Thank you

[Loelya]

Any help would be massively appreciated^-^
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87722022&userid=675816&signature=7t96ecSwuNtE-ZO3-jxaOg

I think this trade could be considered fair.

I broke down in this post evidence for the nonballoon reaching "sorb" level of demand.

I just ran this search on the vr/omgsr success thread for the spotted tribal.

I think these trades indicate a "sorb value" level of demand for the spotted tribal:
spotted tribal + omgsr pickle + 300 C$ for UR ice cat - July 2019
spotted tribal for 800 C$ - Dec 2019
spotted tribal + white Lolita + 2013 store for UR Lion - Jan 2020
spotted tribal for blue toxic - Feb 2020

I think these trades indicate a value higher than a "sorb" in demand for the tribal:
spotted tribal for Hyena Advent + Brown Border Collie Advent + Blue Grinner + Nonballoon + Sheepdog store pet + unicorn store pet - Jan 2020
spotted tribal + wolf pps for ur aussie - Jan 2020
spotted tribal for light speckled rat, WWA, dark shima bwolf, 140 C$, + rares add - March 2020

anyone reading this please do dispute/correct the above value assumptions if you disagree with them. my reasoning from this point is basically: the trades indicating a higher-than-sorb level of demand are more recent than the ones resting right around sorb level, even though there is 1 more of the "sorb" value trades. the more recent evidence may be more helpful in determining current demand.

so the conclusion I would tentatively draw is that the spotted tribal is debatably above sorb level in demand, the nonballoon covers the "sorb" value, and the red x pps is an add to make up for that value gap.

[faygeleh]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87704129&userid=489914&signature=NShiEaI9d2XyYCNnyHUpOg
literally haven't done trades in so long and now I'm just realizing how outdated I am on all of this. Any help is greatly appreciated :3 Thank you

...this is one of the craziest trades ive seen in a while. i would accept this in a heartbeat, personally, because this is MASSIVE overpay. sure, vampiric bats go for a little overpay to bat collectors, but unless im massively missing something?? im pretty sure this particular bat is just a good demand design-- its still only worth around 1-2 '09 rares AT MOST with demand value included. the cheshire cat is currently going for low/mid september lists (14+ '09 rares), EACH 2014 dragon dog is worth 2 '09 rares, the tinsel lion is is a tier 4 advent list worth 6-7 '09 rares, 80 c$ is worth another tier 4 advent, the pony is worth 2 '09 rares, everything else is just small added overpay. dang.

[FOUND VERDICT]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87704129&userid=489914&signature=NShiEaI9d2XyYCNnyHUpOg
literally haven't done trades in so long and now I'm just realizing how outdated I am on all of this. Any help is greatly appreciated :3 Thank you

that is incredibly unfair to them, i really don't know why they'd feel like it's fair...
just the C$ alone is quite some overpay.

i'd let them know they are way over, they don't seem to realize it?

[glitter]

Any help would be massively appreciated^-^
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87722022&userid=675816&signature=7t96ecSwuNtE-ZO3-jxaOg

I think this trade could be considered fair.

I broke down in this post evidence for the nonballoon reaching "sorb" level of demand.

I just ran this search on the vr/omgsr success thread for the spotted tribal.

I think these trades indicate a "sorb value" level of demand for the spotted tribal:
spotted tribal + omgsr pickle + 300 C$ for UR ice cat - July 2019
spotted tribal for 800 C$ - Dec 2019
spotted tribal + white Lolita + 2013 store for UR Lion - Jan 2020
spotted tribal for blue toxic - Feb 2020

I think these trades indicate a value higher than a "sorb" in demand for the tribal:
spotted tribal for Hyena Advent + Brown Border Collie Advent + Blue Grinner + Nonballoon + Sheepdog store pet + unicorn store pet - Jan 2020
spotted tribal + wolf pps for ur aussie - Jan 2020
spotted tribal for light speckled rat, WWA, dark shima bwolf, 140 C$, + rares add - March 2020

anyone reading this please do dispute/correct the above value assumptions if you disagree with them. my reasoning from this point is basically: the trades indicating a higher-than-sorb level of demand are more recent than the ones resting right around sorb level, even though there is 1 more of the "sorb" value trades. the more recent evidence may be more helpful in determining current demand.

so the conclusion I would tentatively draw is that the spotted tribal is debatably above sorb level in demand, the nonballoon covers the "sorb" value, and the red x pps is an add to make up for that value gap.

I agree with what you have to say. However it is worth mentioning that many people do not understand the value of the spotted tribal and I have been told many times that they are worth below a sorb. Personally I found that they are extremely hard to trade off for their value. I got mine for a blue toxic and still have not traded it away from an equal/greater amount.

[OriginalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724501&userid=854251&signature=iN150LDx5J-hjqN-TUszlg

I already got an answer that I was over by a good chunk of C$ (Like 70) and I was looking for another opinion before I cancel/edit ;w;
ty!

[oakfather preserve u]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87720192&userid=670120&signature=ciwbR0wL7xm0TDcYkiwNBQ
not sure why this confuses me so much

pls help!!