The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Loelya]

Help please!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87717577&userid=963983&signature=t_cF4HhWg2sqEq0vDMfI1g

your dog is originally from April 2009, so it would be worth, on a pure rarity basis, four 2010 rares, not three, so this offer is not quite fair on that merit. the following should be taken with a grain of salt, but I have also seen the African wild dog litter appear to have a small uptick in demand, so it is possible that your dog might fetch a bit more than its "base" value.

[faygeleh]

Help please!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87717577&userid=963983&signature=t_cF4HhWg2sqEq0vDMfI1g

unfair to you, your pet is an '09 VR re-release and is worth at least 2 '09 rares. their side is only worth 1.5. they'd have to add at least another '10 rare to make it fair. i got ninja'd while writing this but i agree with the person above that the african wild dog litter has good demand, so you could potentially get more for it, even if its a re-release.

Is this fair?

Thank you in advance for any help! ❤

definitely unfair to them, but a good offer to you if you like the overpay. im pretty sure rarity wise just one of any of those 2013 uncommons would be fair if not overpay on its own, adding that much to their side is definitely over.

edit: accidentally missed this one, sorry!

Is this fair?

the green-fronted holly dog is a tier 10 ex-advent list, worth around 12-13 '09 rares. unless im misremembering, none of their pets are on the rares list, but their side adds up to around 11.5 without considering the high demand of malk cats and sitting cats, but with demand could easily be worth like 14-16 '09 rares or more. i'd say fair/good offer to you if not unfair to them.

[OriginalStar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724501&userid=854251&signature=iN150LDx5J-hjqN-TUszlg

Fair :0?

[faygeleh]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724501&userid=854251&signature=iN150LDx5J-hjqN-TUszlg

Fair :0?

unfair to you, the ghost cat is only a tier 1 advent, and is technically only worth around 65-70 c$, but not any more than 80 at absolute most, even with sitting cat demand. you're already overpaying by at least 70 c$, or double the cat's value-- the hedgehogs on your side is just extra unnecessary overpay.

[~mysticwolf~]

Any help would be massively appreciated^-^
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87722022&userid=675816&signature=7t96ecSwuNtE-ZO3-jxaOg

[OriginalStar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724501&userid=854251&signature=iN150LDx5J-hjqN-TUszlg

Fair :0?

unfair to you, the ghost cat is only a tier 1 advent, and is technically only worth around 65-70 c$, but not any more than 80 at absolute most, even with sitting cat demand. you're already overpaying by at least 70 c$, or double the cat's value-- the hedgehogs on your side is just extra unnecessary overpay.

Thank you! Any other opinions?

[Utakou]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87719921&userid=786321&signature=AlIvgADA-aYCq8BUCgDHAQ

Is this fair? I can't really tell anymore since I haven't played for a while. Thank you so much in advance!!

[Dang It Moon Moon!]

Is this fair?

the green-fronted holly dog is a tier 10 ex-advent list, worth around 12-13 '09 rares. unless im misremembering, none of their pets are on the rares list, but their side adds up to around 11.5 without considering the high demand of malk cats and sitting cats, but with demand could easily be worth like 14-16 '09 rares or more. i'd say fair/good offer to you if not unfair to them.

Thank you ^^

[Owlmania]

Help? I think they're fair rarity wise but I'm wondering if it's fair demand wise.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87724494&userid=963983&signature=ner47a28Bn0jc6147_bDVA

[OriginalStar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87719921&userid=786321&signature=AlIvgADA-aYCq8BUCgDHAQ

Is this fair? I can't really tell anymore since I haven't played for a while. Thank you so much in advance!!

I believe this is unfair to you. They have 1 '09 rare, 1 '10 rare, 1 '12 rare with some more recent rares from 2016 and sooner
Your side is 3 '09 rares and a '10 rare. So they are short by a whole '09 rare and some add since a 2012 rare and some recent rares dont add up to an '09 rare. Feel free for another opinion though!