The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[tennisbutt]

Hi!! So I haven't been on the site in a while and I've lost touch with rarities and such ;v; I was sent this trade and I remember Shima's staff pet was sought after when it was released but don't remember it being that rare?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87542933&userid=39321&signature=oCmKz-Phfr1DDL2ESAHJ5w
I was sent that trade so I was just wondering if it was fair?

[(crow)]

hey, can anyone help with this ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87531288&userid=909970&signature=h65ql6Jeslpyq-bX10rl0g
thanks in advance!

/snip/
Disregard this advice. I was mistaken. Thank you to the user who corrected me.

[Angelhearth]

hey, can anyone help with this ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87531288&userid=909970&signature=h65ql6Jeslpyq-bX10rl0g
thanks in advance!

-snip-.

(Disagree.) The rat is a march 2009 very rare and within the 3 month rule of your January 2009 very rare dog. Rarity wise it would be a fair swap at that point. The Store Pet is probably there to make up for bad demand of the rat.
They don’t have to add anything to make it fair.

*edit*: (crow) made a counting mistake so we decided to delete that comment

[B_e_l_o_v_e_d]

Hello!
I'm not sure about this offer >.<
I would really appreciate any opinion!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87542877&userid=44659&signature=gISU8DZdx6XJyy630nausQ

Thank you very much in advance ^-^

[The Lady Amalthea]

Is this fair? I'm hopeless with c$ trades


trades/viewtrade.php?id=87533816&userid=938809&signature=lq76r6V1j27sLOm4yNQogA

[jaggedfangs]

-snip-.

(Disagree.) The rat is a march 2009 very rare and within the 3 month rule of your January 2009 very rare dog. Rarity wise it would be a fair swap at that point. The Store Pet is probably there to make up for bad demand of the rat.
They don’t have to add anything to make it fair.

*edit*: (crow) made a counting mistake so we decided to delete that comment

thanks!! :))

[- Alice -]

Are these store lists still going for a tier 7 roughly? click

[houndoom]

Are these store lists still going for a tier 7 roughly? click

yes, that seems to be the steady value for the alien dogs : )

[Creativity]

Hello!
I'm not sure about this offer >.<
I would really appreciate any opinion!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87542877&userid=44659&signature=gISU8DZdx6XJyy630nausQ

Thank you very much in advance ^-^

The pets on your side add up to about 4.5 '09 rares - I didn't count the 2017 vcs or the 2020 ucs because in counting and dividing back to '09 rares, their worths would be so abysmally small that it wouldn't make any difference.

Now, the items are a different story. As far as I know, the doves and slanted eyes are going for an '09 rare each, but I've seen a lot of controversy on the worth of the pocky recently. I've seen it going for low-mid advent lists, with occasional overpay due to demand. This may be off, however - it's just what I could gather from a bit of research.

This would be fair if you remove the pocky, because then your side would add up to 7.5 '09 rares, and the Hollyfox dog is a t7 advent worth 7-8 '09 rares.

[~mysticwolf~]

Which of these is the best in terms of auction bid? I'm not great in determining bids for high demand pets, I paid C$700 so do any of these surpass that sort of value, or which is the best?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5

I think either the Grinner one or the two with bulk C$ are probably the best but I'm totally out of the loop with demand etc