The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ahirked]

would this be fair? what is the most my pet can get?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87531028&userid=844191&signature=RWEqYKlNC073bA_a15ptWQ

this is extremely unfair to the top side.
your pet is only worth 4x 2012 uncommons at most.
i advise letting the other user know that they are overpaying.

[the_kiiwii]

How's this? I have seen a lot of these store pets so I figured they will be rare not very rare so Im not sure

And how is this one?

[Christy]

Are these fair offers for a 2010 Malk Smiley ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87523589&userid=992&signature=w77yVxnvducuntwrjzjUOg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87517411&userid=992&signature=6qY95iur9qWOEWTHlF85Xw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516035&userid=992&signature=tLM5LVIo3XHnNASiZDA8Gw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87486324&userid=992&signature=ZTfqxnjtCdxEqdKdKz9fMg

Thank you ^^

[Rbpuppy]

Heyo, I was wondering if this trade is fair for my Shima. Thanks in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=87536278&userid=749246&signature=Qt6YCdsMimOX8MR_3oNTLg

This is over pay even with demand and rarity wise the Shima is only an 09 Rare.

[Angelhearth]

Heyo, I was wondering if this trade is fair for my Shima. Thanks in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=87536278&userid=749246&signature=Qt6YCdsMimOX8MR_3oNTLg

This is over pay even with demand and rarity wise the Shima is only an 09 Rare.

With Demand the Shima is worth more than a 09 rare! It can even go for lists! I don’t know if 300 C$ is fair, but the statement that the Shima is worth a 09 rare with demand is simply false.

[FOUND VERDICT]

Heyo, I was wondering if this trade is fair for my Shima. Thanks in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=87536278&userid=749246&signature=Qt6YCdsMimOX8MR_3oNTLg

This is over pay even with demand and rarity wise the Shima is only an 09 Rare.

With Demand the Shima is worth more than a 09 rare! It can even go for lists! I don’t know if 300 C$ is fair, but the statement that the Shima is worth a 09 rare with demand is simply false.

the shima is worth an 09 rare. demand doesn't change the actual worth of a pet.
his current trading value is higher though, i'd say 300C$ is a nice offer.

[xxhunterxx]

is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=87537702&userid=396455&signature=aGYFm8RfaPzQILcndGhK1Q idk the values

[the_kiiwii]

How's this? I have seen a lot of these store pets so I figured they will be rare not very rare so Im not sure

And how is this one?

[kayyye]

is this fair?
*bulk trade*

this too please ♡

and this <:

[Angelhearth]

is this fair?
*bulk trade*

this too please ♡

and this <:

First trade: Unfair to you. The oldest 18 bunnies are already worth 2 2010 rares and one 2013 rare and a 2014 rare. Their side doesn’t cover that. New Store pets are only worth a 2010-2011 rare each and the C$ would pay for the 2014 rare. The rest doesn’t come to covering the 2013 rare not even mentioning the bunnies that I didn’t tranfer into rares.