The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[KathrynKat]

Would this offer be fair for my white guinea pig?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535601&userid=245230&signature=68Y6qlI5GPySOPgCmhewVA

[BunnyBeam]

Is this fair?

Thanks in advance!

[gudetama]

How's this? I have seen a lot of these store pets so I figured they will be rare not very rare so Im not sure

And how is this one?

first is a fair swap, as this months store pets go for '10 rares. the second is a bit overpay on their side as a '15 store pet is worth 45-50c$

[~mysticwolf~]

So I'm auctioning off my PPS dragon cat and wanted opinions on these bids. I paid C$700 plus a couple pets for it so was wondering compared to what I paid how good these bids are and which are the best (I know it has ridiculous demand and so am very unsure about it all tbh ^-^)
Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8

I think either the Grinner one or the two with bulk C$ are probably the best but I'm totally out of the loop with demand etc

Any help on which is best value would be extremely appreciated ^-^

[miilk]

Heyo, I was wondering if this trade is fair for my Shima. Thanks in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=87536278&userid=749246&signature=Qt6YCdsMimOX8MR_3oNTLg

[gudetama]

would this be fair? what is the most my pet can get?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87531028&userid=844191&signature=RWEqYKlNC073bA_a15ptWQ

[Spiritthesly]

Hi! Is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87533753&userid=660665&signature=TX802wZPqZrnLOF6lf4H4g

Thanks!

[kkspecial4]

Heyo, I was wondering if this trade is fair for my Shima. Thanks in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=87536278&userid=749246&signature=Qt6YCdsMimOX8MR_3oNTLg

Shima LT = Late 2009 Rare = 35-40 c$

If you value the Shima LT at a mid advent, it would be worth roughly 95-100 C$

Preference of C$ or the Shima LT is up to you - as is really any demand

Fairness wise, based only on the above they are overpaying with the C$ - but again preference and demand is up to you
Feel free to get a second opinion - I personally have not traded a Shima LT in a while

[Meredy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535969&userid=989718&signature=diGR3YvKp072-lNTcsb9rw
is this fair?

[Skye Selkie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535969&userid=989718&signature=diGR3YvKp072-lNTcsb9rw
is this fair?

'09 very rares are worth c$45-55 so a little overpay on the c$ end