The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[rycbar]

Hi, I was wondering if this offer I received is fair? I’m a person who’s somewhat uncomfortable declining offers and I don’t want to be unreasonable, especially since they were nice, but I’m not sure how I feel about this trade. I don’t know rarities very well, and it doesn’t help that I’ve been gone for the last 5 years. I would appreciate advice

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87534729&userid=699068&signature=NCZ77A0jD_tbJZ03ytR6Yg

A 2014 rare is worth 2 2014 uncommons, or 1 2013 uncommon. Even if you value a rare at 4 uncommons (some people do), your pet is worth, at most, 1 2012 uncommon. They're overpaying.

Thanks very much! This is why I need to come here. I wasn’t really sure what the years meant...

[muffy]

was this fair? Or a good trade?

[jaggedfangs]

I got another trade for my rat

Is this fair?

Thanks in advance!

i'd say they are underpaying. even according to this thread in which its worth was lower as it was not omgsr yet, still had its price higher. i don't think personally you should take it.

[Jess72005]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535576&userid=828357&signature=-JEslFpCLkI-FjpGQBTxKA

Is this fair? Personally I feel like I'm overpaying as mine are store pets.
Thanks in advance for any help ♥

[jaggedfangs]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535576&userid=828357&signature=-JEslFpCLkI-FjpGQBTxKA

Is this fair? Personally I feel like I'm overpaying as mine are store pets.
Thanks in advance for any help ♥

you are overpaying by a whole lot. 2020 store pets are valued at late '10 rares and what they're offering wouldn't even make up for one '10 rare.

[phxyvi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535576&userid=828357&signature=-JEslFpCLkI-FjpGQBTxKA

Is this fair? Personally I feel like I'm overpaying as mine are store pets.
Thanks in advance for any help ♥

Their side is worth a bit more than a 2016 rare and your side is worth an 09

[Jess72005]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535576&userid=828357&signature=-JEslFpCLkI-FjpGQBTxKA

Is this fair? Personally I feel like I'm overpaying as mine are store pets.
Thanks in advance for any help ♥

you are overpaying by a whole lot. 2020 store pets are valued at late '10 rares and what they're offering wouldn't even make up for one '10 rare.

Ty! This is what I was thinking haha

[Ice_Dragon]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87532856&userid=783020&signature=hBiRXZ0e-MFe3Jj2plEX2g

Please help

Please please please!

[Jess72005]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87535576&userid=828357&signature=-JEslFpCLkI-FjpGQBTxKA

Is this fair? Personally I feel like I'm overpaying as mine are store pets.
Thanks in advance for any help ♥

Their side is worth a bit more than a 2016 rare and your side is worth an 09

Oh wow ok, ty for your help !!

[spirit • daydream]

Hey could I get another opinion please? Thank you in advance ^^
Is this fair?


Also I need help with this one ^^
Trade