The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mouse 13]

I'm looking to trade this group for a Ur Phoenix. How much more would I need to add? Or am I getting close to the value?

[cherri ♥︎]

hey!
is this bid fair?
if not how would you rate it and how much more do you think i can get?

[ahirked]

I'm horrible with items but I do know the medieval faire items have good demand.
Would any of those two trades be fair to me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87528334&userid=751686&signature=oIIHYl57oCSVgMMVBcVmag
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87528350&userid=751686&signature=1ObgA9MqtMC31gtSNWvWIQ

Thank you!

first trade-
- silver moon = current store item, worth ~1c$ individually
- bunny = 2011 uc
- light dragon = 2011 uc/r
- cait sidhe = 2015 c/uc
the silver moon doesn't seem to have any particular worth, and i didn't find anything on the item worth thread, esp. as it's readily available from the store. i'd say it's fair, but get a second opinion jic.

second trade-
- striped black hoodie = 5c$, still in store
- bunny = 2011 uc
- dark & light dragon = 2011 uc/r ea.
- pointy wizard hat & mirror necklace = 2011 c/uc ea.
- cait sidhe = 2015 c/uc
- galaxy witch hats x2 & deer/lion/croc skull = 2017 c/uc ea.
- 20x 2019 items = 2019 c ea.
- 2x 2020 items = 2020 c ea.

i'd say they're underpaying. 4 2013 uc = 2011 uc, and they haven't added enough to cover the 2011 items.
- hoodie = 2013 uc
- bunny & dragons = 2010 r (if valuing dragons at uc; if you value them at a rare, then the 2010 r does not cover the bunny)
- pointy wizard hat (valuing at a common) = 2013 uc + 2014 uc + 2 2015 uc
that leaves the 2x 2016 uc, which are only worth a 2013 omgsc together.
so yeah, no, this isn't fair to you because their side barely covers the hoodie, bunny, dragons and pointy wizard hat.

[dog motif]

Any opinions on this small trade? Thanks in advance! <3

[jaggedfangs]

Any opinions on this small trade? Thanks in advance! <3

unfair to you in my opinion but if you're interested in these particular pets and items then you can go for it i guess

[ahirked]

Any opinions on this small trade? Thanks in advance! <3

if you follow the 2:1 rule then a 2010 rare = 2 2011 rares.
unfair to you.

[Angelhearth]

Is this fair?
Trade includes items and rares

And this one?
Trade includes 200 C$ and a T5 Ex-Advent List

If not fair, what would need to be added on either side?

[jaggedfangs]

Is this fair?
Trade includes items and rares

And this one?
Trade includes 200 C$ and a T5 Ex-Advent List

If not fair, what would need to be added on either side?

second trade: i'd say you are overpaying according to this thread, and i haven't seen this dog have insane demand either to think they are being fair. not sure what you could add but a T5 is worth around 85-100 depending on what you value it at. maybe a T7 or T8 would be fair to add? not sure. i can't give opinions on first trade as i don't know much on items

[bee ♥]

Would the UR apple and cucumber be fair for the pink balloon dog?

[ahirked]

Is this fair?
Trade includes items and rares

And this one?
Trade includes 200 C$ and a T5 Ex-Advent List

If not fair, what would need to be added on either side?

first trade-
- devil wings = 2011 uc
- tears, jungle necklace = freebie items(?), recent c/uc ea.
- sitting cat plush = 2013 c/uc
- selkie = 2015 c/uc
- dandelion chain = 2016 c
- broken heart tatt = 2017 c
- panther plushie = 2018 c/uc
- lovebirds = 2019 c
they're overpaying just with the 2010 rare alone. a 2011 uc is a 2010 c at most, and the rest of the items go into vc/omgsc deductions. unfair to them.