The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jaggedfangs]

Got another I need an opinion on, please?

i'd say this is unfair to you. the cat is several places higher than the flower pot and i'd say despite its good demand the bmd does not make up for it. what they're offering i'd say doesn't even add up to a non, while the cat is worth 2 nons & 2 sorbets.
(note that i haven't been on here so demand might have changed. i'm going off the rares list i used to know)

[Angelhearth]

Is this fair?
Trade includes items and rares

And this one?
Trade includes 200 C$ and a T5 Ex-Advent List

If not fair, what would need to be added on either side?

[VashTheStampede]

Got another I need an opinion on, please?

i'd say this is unfair to you. the cat is several places higher than the flower pot and i'd say despite its good demand the bmd does not make up for it. what they're offering i'd say doesn't even add up to a non, while the cat is worth 2 nons & 2 sorbets.
(note that i haven't been on here so demand might have changed. i'm going off the rares list i used to know)

Thank you.

Anyone have advice on this one that just came in?

[phxyvi]

i'd say this is unfair to you. the cat is several places higher than the flower pot and i'd say despite its good demand the bmd does not make up for it. what they're offering i'd say doesn't even add up to a non, while the cat is worth 2 nons & 2 sorbets.
(note that i haven't been on here so demand might have changed. i'm going off the rares list i used to know)

Thank you.

Anyone have advice on this one that just came in?

The first trade,
Flowerpot is .5-1 and bmd is .5

Their side is 1.5 max and yours is 2-3

Second trade

The dog tag is 1.5-2, typically the lower end, and the cat is 2-3
The c$ doesn’t cover what they would need to add imo

[kayyye]

is this fair?
*bulk trade*

this too please ♡

[VashTheStampede]

Thank you all for the advice on the other trades.

Am I overpaying by a lot with this trade and this one? Pretty sure I am rarity wise (and I know I definitely am for the second one), but what about demand?

[cherri ♥︎]

hey!
is this bid fair?
if not how would you rate it and how much more do you think i can get?

[InfernoSis]

Is this a fair trade?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87527589&userid=290227&signature=WhldzU7IadphNTgMhaiasA

Edit: the last 2 bunnies will be removed regardless wether it would be a fair trade or not

[Ruruskadoo]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87527709&userid=119355&signature=5Dqw-H9-_bfLBKk2Ng9Wcg

[ahirked]

Thank you all for the advice on the other trades.

Am I overpaying by a lot with this trade and this one? Pretty sure I am rarity wise (and I know I definitely am for the second one), but what about demand?

zodiacs trade for 2 2009 rares ea., so a full set would be worth 24 2009 rares.
your side has:
- 4 2009 vr = 8 2009 rares
- 3 2010 r = 1 2009 r + 2009 uc
- 6 2011 r & 2 2011 uc = 4 2009 r + 2 2009 uc + 2010 uc
- 4 2012 r = 2010 r or 2 2009 uc
- 2013 r = 2011 uc
- 40 c$ = roughly 2010 vr = 2009 r
total = 15 2009 rares + 2009 uc + 2010 uc + 2011 uc
(4 2009 uc = 2009 r so i've just added up corresponding values).
so your side has a little over 15 2009 rares worth. so demand-wise you are underpaying, but rarity-wise, yes, you are overpaying.

as for the second trade, again:
- 4 2009 vrs + 3 2009 r = 11 2009 rares
- 16 2010 r = 8 2009 r
- 11 2011 r = 2 2009 r + 3 2009 uc
- 3 2012 r = 3 2010 uc
- 3 2013 r = 3 2011 uc
- 2 2014 r
- 5 2016
- 2 2017
total = 21 2009 r + 3 2009 uc + 3 2010 uc + 3 2011 uc
could not for the life of me find the bw in the archive so i haven't factored it into the total, but this roughs out at 21 2009 rares + add. again, i haven't done 2014 onward because the space between those rares and 2009/2010/2011 uc get bigger and bigger and we would be getting into vc/omgsc conversions.

please get a second opinion in case i have gone wrong along the way, but from my understanding neither of these trades are fair in terms of demand. otherwise, drastic overpay on rarity terms.

edit: bw is 2008 rerelease, worth 1 2009 r + 2009 uc

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87527709&userid=119355&signature=5Dqw-H9-_bfLBKk2Ng9Wcg

2015 rare = 2011 vc / 2012 c.
you're overpaying. your side is worth a 2011 rare + add.