The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Pumpkin~Spice]

Hi, is this fair? What needs to be added or taken away?
Click
Any help is appreciated.

[madisong]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86722529&userid=793046&signature=QAMVUXMz-6txgnRhcqLr4A

I'm having a hard time deciding if it's worth it....

It’s considerably unfair to you.
The punk dog trades for around a sorbet. If you value 12 MAs @ a non, they’d need to trade 6 MAs to make it fair to you. They’re only offering 3 plus a low advent.

[Sylvia]

Could someone help me with this?
Thank you!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86673645&userid=1464&signature=5SAjXLGA1NAGuSwShzWWkg

[kxynine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86722529&userid=793046&signature=QAMVUXMz-6txgnRhcqLr4A

I'm having a hard time deciding if it's worth it....

It’s considerably unfair to you.
The punk dog trades for around a sorbet. If you value 12 MAs @ a non, they’d need to trade 6 MAs to make it fair to you. They’re only offering 3 plus a low advent.

Thanks

Could I possibly get more opinions?

[CaseyBaby]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86723520&userid=457960&signature=ooRoaIJyh5W0hNXxcBQAMw
fair?

[executable]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86723520&userid=457960&signature=ooRoaIJyh5W0hNXxcBQAMw
fair?

No, you’re offering on a pet worth over a non, and one that has pretty good demand.

[reze]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86723520&userid=457960&signature=ooRoaIJyh5W0hNXxcBQAMw
fair?

theyre over by a ***lot***. your pets arent anywhere close to being worth what their strawb is. their strawberry is worth 1-1.5 nons which would be 100-200 '09 rares. and your side doesnt even add up to one 09 rare

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86722529&userid=793046&signature=QAMVUXMz-6txgnRhcqLr4A

I'm having a hard time deciding if it's worth it....

It’s considerably unfair to you.
The punk dog trades for around a sorbet. If you value 12 MAs @ a non, they’d need to trade 6 MAs to make it fair to you. They’re only offering 3 plus a low advent.

Thanks

Could I possibly get more opinions?

i'd second that. considering a solid market value of a sorbet for the punk dog, this wouldn't be fair in the slightest. to make it fair they'd need to double their offer.

however, I will say that the punk dog is unlikely to actually be worth a sorbet, realistically, and if you just happen to value it at less that's entirely fine too. the job of this thread is to make people aware of what's widely considered fair and what isn't, not really to make people's choices for them. i'd strongly recommend asking them to add 2-3 mid advents but at the end of the day if you're happy that's fine, too.

[phxyvi]

It’s considerably unfair to you.
The punk dog trades for around a sorbet. If you value 12 MAs @ a non, they’d need to trade 6 MAs to make it fair to you. They’re only offering 3 plus a low advent.

Thanks

Could I possibly get more opinions?

i'd second that. considering a solid market value of a sorbet for the punk dog, this wouldn't be fair in the slightest. to make it fair they'd need to double their offer.

however, I will say that the punk dog is unlikely to actually be worth a sorbet, realistically, and if you just happen to value it at less that's entirely fine too. the job of this thread is to make people aware of what's widely considered fair and what isn't, not really to make people's choices for them. i'd strongly recommend asking them to add 2-3 mid advents but at the end of the day if you're happy that's fine, too.

It’s all’s worth noting the dark wood dog isn’t a mid advent?
Also a sorbet tends to be around 7 as 5-6 is too low and makes Septembers relatively impossible.

They’re already impossible but moreso when you drop a sorbet down to a mere 5 advents

[Elegant_Coffee]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86723801&userid=974515&signature=ZFHhTUZJt_EyxsZq65Ee-A
is this fair?