The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Gajevy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86689804&userid=952637&signature=hl1OCXL453UZDtvmjtxTVw

What about this? It’s a bid for my auction!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86683922&userid=952637&signature=3x9TA4Xat1Nph2TsrcYXwQ

So need second opinion with this, demand wise would you guys take this?

Not sure about the second one but I find that Rabbits/rodent's are always less than what they are worth. Also the fact that they are wanting to give you a double in my opinion is also unfair towards you since during auctions you have to try get as much as possible

[kököchin]

how's this trade i sent ??
thank you to the replies in advance <33
feel free to pm me if you'd prefer that as well ( :

also!! what would you all say the drink me is going for currently? i've had a lot of offers cancelled because my trading partners value the drink me @ 6 nons. i just wanted to validate that here~

thank you all again for the responses in advance. i know i'm kind of asking for a lot ;;

[quitting99983]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86689804&userid=952637&signature=hl1OCXL453UZDtvmjtxTVw

What about this? It’s a bid for my auction!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86683922&userid=952637&signature=3x9TA4Xat1Nph2TsrcYXwQ

So need second opinion with this, demand wise would you guys take this?

Not sure about the second one but I find that Rabbits/rodent's are always less than what they are worth. Also the fact that they are wanting to give you a double in my opinion is also unfair towards you since during auctions you have to try get as much as possible

that's wrong. know your pets when you're responding with help. those are very good store jackalopes on the advent list. it's a fantastic bid for a grinner and they will only increase in value. the second bid is overpay, as it is a september list pet for your advent christmas tree dog.

[reze]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86689804&userid=952637&signature=hl1OCXL453UZDtvmjtxTVw

What about this? It’s a bid for my auction!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86683922&userid=952637&signature=3x9TA4Xat1Nph2TsrcYXwQ

So need second opinion with this, demand wise would you guys take this?

Not sure about the second one but I find that Rabbits/rodent's are always less than what they are worth. Also the fact that they are wanting to give you a double in my opinion is also unfair towards you since during auctions you have to try get as much as possible

how exactly are rabbits "less than what they are worth"? what about the skelebun? please do not give out inaccurate advice, those jackalopes have pretty regular demand and go for T7s..

[iero]

?

[The Score]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86694026&userid=609083&signature=ZjYFk2mx-ixNq08wzFhLEQ

Help!!!

[MEAT!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86694026&userid=609083&signature=ZjYFk2mx-ixNq08wzFhLEQ

Help!!!

the top is overpaying; your butterfly wolf had an extended release into mid/late 2009, thus making it worth a mid/late '09 rare. your trade partner is overpaying by about an '09 rare

[Fizzlebee]

Hi guys, I've received two trades involving my griffin store dog set that I'd love to get opinions on. I haven't been very active on CS in recent years, so I'm really not sure what is fair for the set these days. Same with the other store pets involved in the second one. Thanks for any help!

Trade 1
Trade 2

[DPVSChicken]

Hi guys, I just want to be sure I am being fair in this trade ( trades/viewtrade.php?id=86695114&userid=1652&signature=DpzXQSo2vIJGH8ti5zoLXQ ) . I don't mind the fact that I am trading down, but is it correct that the overall value of all of those pets are equal to just 1 2010 rare?
I am going with the rule of 1 (year) rare is equal to 2 (next year) rare or 4 (2 years later) rare, or 16 (3 year later) rare. And that 2 uncommons = 1 rare, and 2 commons = 1 uncommon. If those overall ratios are not correct, please let me know.

[kököchin]

how's this trade i sent ??
thank you to the replies in advance <33
feel free to pm me if you'd prefer that as well ( :

also!! what would you all say the drink me is going for currently? i've had a lot of offers cancelled because my trading partners value the drink me @ 6 nons. i just wanted to validate that here~

thank you all again for the responses in advance. i know i'm kind of asking for a lot ;;