The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[metanoia.]

should I do this trade for their sunjewl?

also can I get an opinion on this?

for the sunjewel, i wouldn't do that. the non-jewel and sunjewel are in the same litter, but i believe the sunjewel is a tad more. the zebra is roughly 1.5 non i believe, so with those two you may have a fair trade with slight overpay, not so sure. but with both plus an add on and 700+ c$, i would say that this is unfair to you. its complete overpay i believe. you should get a second opinion, however.

with the second trade i would say that this is underpay. the non-jewel is 1-2 nons i believe, not sure again, and i do not think this adds up. you should get a secon opinion as i don't think i am correct on the values.

[reze]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86468054&userid=954562&signature=Z9yR2t_OzO8dhCz3d3dO6g

Is this fair?

no, your pet is not only a rare, but it is also older, from 2011. unless you hoard the flower dogs, but then again, there's only 9 of them so it's not really worth a 2011 rare even in quantity, so idk, i would personally not do it as it's unfair but it's up to you.

[phxyvi]

should I do this trade for their sunjewl?

also can I get an opinion on this?

for the sunjewel, i wouldn't do that. the non-jewel and sunjewel are in the same litter, but i believe the sunjewel is a tad more. the zebra is roughly 1.5 non i believe, so with those two you may have a fair trade with slight overpay, not so sure. but with both plus an add on and 700+ c$, i would say that this is unfair to you. its complete overpay i believe. you should get a second opinion, however.

with the second trade i would say that this is underpay. the non-jewel is 1-2 nons i believe, not sure again, and i do not think this adds up. you should get a secon opinion as i don't think i am correct on the values. :)

For the sunjewel, your side is around 3-4

I would personally remove the c$ From your side

[kököchin]

should I do this trade for their sunjewl?

also can I get an opinion on this?

for the sunjewel, i wouldn't do that. the non-jewel and sunjewel are in the same litter, but i believe the sunjewel is a tad more. the zebra is roughly 1.5 non i believe, so with those two you may have a fair trade with slight overpay, not so sure. but with both plus an add on and 700+ c$, i would say that this is unfair to you. its complete overpay i believe. you should get a second opinion, however.

with the second trade i would say that this is underpay. the non-jewel is 1-2 nons i believe, not sure again, and i do not think this adds up. you should get a secon opinion as i don't think i am correct on the values.

agreed but i'd like to clarify a bit more c:
as for the first trade, the sunjewel is worth around 5 nons rarity wise, however demand wise only tends to go for 3 or 4. i, personally, would not take that trade as the jewel does not have the best demand and is not as favorable as it was in prior years. if you were to take it, however, i would remove the unnecessary c$.

as for the second trade, that is immensely unfair to you. the nonjewel with its value of a non goes for around 100-200 09 rares if you wanted to do a bulk trade down, hence making their side extremely unfair to you.

[sillies]

Got one opinion on the previous thread, but wanted to get one more on this trade, thanks!

[(^-^)]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86468054&userid=954562&signature=Z9yR2t_OzO8dhCz3d3dO6g

Is this fair?

no, your pet is not only a rare, but it is also older, from 2011. unless you hoard the flower dogs, but then again, there's only 9 of them so it's not really worth a 2011 rare even in quantity, so idk, i would personally not do it as it's unfair but it's up to you.

Ok thank youu

[executable]

Got one opinion on the previous thread, but wanted to get one more on this trade, thanks!

Your side is roughly three-four nons (Lolita being 1, coontail being 2, c$ being a little less than a non). The red cerb can go for, on average, 3-4, so I’d say it looks pretty good.

[Jiloon]

What do you guys think about this trade? I'm not sure what the UR Tiger is going for anymore, I still value midway between demand and actual worth, leaning towards demand. Any help would be super appreciated!

[executable]

What do you guys think about this trade? I'm not sure what the UR Tiger is going for anymore, I still value midway between demand and actual worth, leaning towards demand. Any help would be super appreciated!

5-6 mins is what it’s usually worth, not sure their side adds up to that (all the pets offered go for about a non each).

[phxyvi]

What do you guys think about this trade? I'm not sure what the UR Tiger is going for anymore, I still value midway between demand and actual worth, leaning towards demand. Any help would be super appreciated!

The tiger goes around 6 nons

Personally I value the joker @ 1 regardless of date as it simply isn’t much rarer than a regular 08 to call it special when it’s td
However, I will acknowledge some say 2 due to it being td

The cats are 1-1.5

And the ceg is 1-1.5


So 6.5 at the most, 4 at the least possible value.