"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[RainbowPeanut]

I'm not very good with list trades so if someone could help me I'd really appreciate it! Still using the list pets logic that is hahA

[tiff.]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86289641&userid=412178&signature=hme1GF6svAeKvgVH7yGzVw

and this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86291825&userid=412178&signature=CCNABemGRvNH2STpwtijkQ

thanks!!

[barioth]

what do you guys think of these bids

1
2
3
4

I also have two separate swap trades for a green sorb and a yellow sorb, which i really like over the pink and the blue, since they're my favourites. but i might accept a bid instead and get another sorb later.

[Gympie]

Help please!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86296202&userid=950685&signature=X8NiIyMwFOdnmKhPo172yA

[Fallenleaf]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86295654&userid=867789&signature=SfX7hGLX6SPmadjEDByVGw
AHh please help and demand wise please too if not, can someone tell me what my pets would be worth total?
This too please: I don’t know advent worth too much all I know is their Pet is a T7 but mine is a tier2 store..both have pretty good demand I think trades/viewtrade.php?id=86296207&userid=867789&signature=EbXtAFbcNH70jpExqH8c2Q

[Azgeda]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86295654&userid=867789&signature=SfX7hGLX6SPmadjEDByVGw
AHh please help and demand wise please too if not, can someone tell me what my pets would be worth total?

The horse is a Tier 7 September Palomino, Valued at 220-230C$ according to the ex list and the List C$ Guide. Personally demand fir the horse might raise or lower the C$ value a bit.

You have a Tier 2 Advent list Zebra Carasoul horse and a Tier 1 Advent Cream/Blue Fluffy Store Dog.

Technically, Rarity Wise they would be overpaying. HOWEVER, my experience you can get massive overpay for store Pets if you auction them/advertise them and have patience.
I sold my "brown fluffy store dog", the littermate to your Cream/Blue fluffy store dog for 100C$, sitting warrior (which I sold for 95), plus 2 other high demand pets. Which I roughly added to 200, not including the two pets I've yet to sale.
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86290683&userid=124900&signature=Qp9jMRrOGjEtlHKhCepPMQ <-Keep in mind I sold this pet today, so that is accurate as of today.

With the Carasoul horse I really wasnt able to find many results on it. So you might want to get an opinion there, as I've never owned or sold any.

I know people probably dont agree with the way I value store pets, but I urge you to keep in mind Store pets are never rereleased, while any Rare/Very Rare/OMGSR is. To me, this makes older store pets twice as valuable, at least, then other pets of its tier. Especially store pets with high demand.

Please get more opinions and good luck ♡

[jointedwishes]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86286443&userid=961979&signature=UUR6bNbk51sJXDGYkfSQYg

Is this trade fair rarity and demand wise? Thank you in advance <3
edit;
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86293855&userid=961979&signature=0dGFfjWNVdUhJUNA8DMBfg
this one aswell?

been asking for 6+ pages now <3

another edit, this trade was sent in:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86295659&userid=961979&signature=fNW6tVh86FupqZzuU4oXcg

another another edit:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86295666&userid=961979&signature=nRGv1if9HQPpT4vWYfrRWQ

[albino polar bear]

.

[Azgeda]

[quote="Kitten toes"]Help please!!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86296202&userid=950685&signature=X8NiIyMwFOdnmKhPo172yA[/quotethey are offering a They are offering a Tier 1 Ghost cat, Advent list.
You have a tier 7 PPS boar, Advent list, and an African wild dog.

Rarity wise this is unfair to the Boar PPS.

[lukas_stop]

Is it fair? I know the White February is an XList but I'm unfamiliar with the list in general.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86285323&userid=779487&signature=g1xBcR0zGZCslYkYL8ZS9w

The white febuary has excellent demand, but it was not an ex-list
If you go off rarity the white feb is only worth the three month rule. Personally, considering the demand for the '09 tree is pretty good as well, it isn't a bad offer. I'd take it imo

Regardless it is very unfair to the top. A straight swap for either one of the malk horses would be fair for the white feb.