"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[Karnaca]

Hey, I got three bids on my UR Holly dog, would these be fair demand wise? Would you accept (one of) the trades if you had the Holly dog? Thank you so much for any opinions!


UR Foal for UR Holly

UR Strawberry for UR Holly

Joker bun for UR Holly

[-Compass-]

hello! Opinions?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86133759&userid=125647&signature=IlvsJReV4Lyukub9WeboYg
have a good day!

each of your items is worth a late 09 rare according to the CS items guide. however, just like store pets, items don't get re-released and as such I believe the guide is outdated and your items are probably worth more. I definitely wouldn't take this.

thank you for your help!

[Karnaca]

Hey, I got three bids on my UR Holly dog, would these be fair demand wise? Would you accept (one of) the trades if you had the Holly dog? Thank you so much for any opinions!


UR Foal for UR Holly

UR Strawberry for UR Holly

Joker bun for UR Holly

[Black Clover]

cake dog for shy/tan basilisk?

[ghostbite]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86146710&userid=678772&signature=z0htivufLZ00cJBcQWlNJw

I'm not quite sure if this trade is fair, if not how much C$ would they be worth?

[saint]

UR aussie dog for nontag?

[Ice_Dragon]

I’m so bad with exlist

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86153428&userid=783020&signature=FDjK-gcan8qCACczvs6acQ

[executable]

I’m so bad with exlist

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86153428&userid=783020&signature=FDjK-gcan8qCACczvs6acQ

Unfair to the bottom. The red dragon is a September list pet while the rat is a mainlist.

[Loelya]

Hey, I got three bids on my UR Holly dog, would these be fair demand wise? Would you accept (one of) the trades if you had the Holly dog? Thank you so much for any opinions!


UR Foal for UR Holly

UR Strawberry for UR Holly

Joker bun for UR Holly

second link is broken!

The UR Holly, UR Foal, and the UR strawberry all tend to fluctuate in the same demand range; I personally would call either the Foal or the Strawberry a fair swap demand-wise for the Holly. If the strawberry bid also has an add, it might be a matter of deciding which pet and/or add you prefer.

If I were running the auction myself I would probably take the strawberry because I like that pet better than the Holly, but that’s just my personal preference.

The UR Foal is closest in value to the UR Holly rarity-wise, however. The joker bun is technically the “lowest” of the bids both demand-wise and rarity-wise, but its demand pretty consistently rests at the lower end of the Holly’s fluctuating demand, so its not an unfair offer either.

UR aussie dog for nontag?

perfectly fair swap demand-wise. Rarity-wise, the Aussie is underpay for the nontag.

[VictorianBat]

Urgent! Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=86153557&userid=978212&signature=_S5SfJojiHRjQcLmxGfqEg