"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86146467&userid=709218&signature=uKxldcl8dNQ8xx1eJGi_ag

Rarity wise, their side only adds up to 1.5 '09 rares (the warrior cat was extended into 2010). Many people value 2008 very rares around 2-4 '09 rares.
Demand is up to you. The warrior tends to get overpay.

[Aleigh]

hi I just wanna quickly ask if this is fair demand wise, with the list discontinued I'm very weary and like I've heard the strawberry can be hard to trade off lmao thanks

[Legendarypawprint]

Hi, is this a fair trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86127034&userid=805505&signature=6CMfrhE79Ka1Z2005DoA_A

[Brackensnake]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86147109&userid=781035&signature=3-V9ajOOCzOoQUaQMXlRFA

Is this fair? If not what can be done to make it fair?

[Frozen_Cherry]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86136996&userid=725461&signature=NV0MxP5sP3hs3mrAeGKd_A

and

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86138939&userid=725461&signature=Dg5LkDYWochABiQzXE_dNA

[Legendarypawprint]

Hi, is this a fair trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86127034&userid=805505&signature=6CMfrhE79Ka1Z2005DoA_A

[Ice_Dragon]

Please help, I’m clueless
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86147940&userid=783020&signature=9jWdojcJUgoqxeeqrvcHjA

[Hauntednightmares]

Should I take an UR strawberry for my UR holy dog? Would you personally?

[W0LF]

Please help, I’m clueless
trades/viewtrade.php?id=86147940&userid=783020&signature=9jWdojcJUgoqxeeqrvcHjA

The Bumblebee Spider was a T1 Advent on the now retired Rares List
The C$ value of a T1 is about 65C$.

Consider each of the store pets are worth 20C$ each or slightly more, as they are no longer available in the store.

I want to point out that on the retired List thread it says the Bumblebee Spider's placement was
"possibly going to be moved up or down."
...To be moved down would be to be removed from the list altogether, & I've never heard of a pet being removed once added... which leads me to believe that it would have been placed higher.
By how much (if at all?) we will never know.

Still, my opinion is that this is a very decent offer.

[W0LF]

hi I just wanna quickly ask if this is fair demand wise, with the list discontinued I'm very weary and like I've heard the strawberry can be hard to trade off lmao thanks

Should I take an UR strawberry for my UR holy dog? Would you personally?

If I am completely candid, I am unsertain what the UR Holly Dog goes for these days.
However, personally...
Upon release, someone offered me the UR Strawberry
in exchange for the UR Malk, & Malk PPS pup.
I accepted, & I don't regret it.
I suppose it largely depends on which pet you like more?
From my own experience, the Strawberry gets quite a bit of attention, & has had fairly decent demand since its release.
(I've also seen someone who is actively hoarding them, though I'm not sure what they offer.)