"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[Smaug The Dragon]

I'd like some last few opinions on this trade before accepting. We both value the green liontail at 3 nons because of demand. Would like fast replies please. <3

Thank you to everyone!
I've gotten mixed responses and would like a few more just in case. The liontail should also turn OMGSR come turns

[Toxxic_22]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86042768&userid=970881&signature=whCZOK3e-87eb_FzyuKzyA

they asked which one I would trade for what would be my best bet?

[Fishcat]

is a yellow sorb for a red cerberus fair/unfair over/under? demand/rarity wise?

[solos]

is a coontail worth more than the july pps? ik that it’s the same tier but i recently saw something where the coontail is worth more..

[amarok.]

is a yellow sorb for a red cerberus fair/unfair over/under? demand/rarity wise?

It's fair, quite possibly overpay on the sorbet side (but it's hard to tell exactly where the red cerb falls rarity wise), but the red cerb invariably trades for a rather daft amount of overpay and people like to say that a trade isn't "fair" if that margin of overpay isn't met. Demand wise, a red cerb fetches around 3+ nons (or 6+ sorbets) and I've not seen one go for less in a long while.

is a coontail worth more than the july pps? ik that it’s the same tier but i recently saw something where the coontail is worth more..

The July PPS is worth a lot more than the coontail, but the coontail is usually valued higher/trades for more due to the july pps' poor demand. The coontail fetches 2ish nons, though seems to be fetching slightly below that for some reason currently, and the July PPS floats between 1-1.5 nons, usually at the lower end.

My source is here; Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4201164

[Galifey]

is this fair? Thanks for your help!

[Toxxic_22]

is this fair? Thanks for your help!

Unfair to you their sides doesn't add up to a your '11 UC

[phxyvi]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86043592&userid=967730&signature=gEM9U8SCBs2FjasZPv4M2g

[♥HazelNightmare]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86043592&userid=967730&signature=gEM9U8SCBs2FjasZPv4M2g

Rarity wise 2014 store pets are worth a 2009 rare, haven’t seen many that will actually trade one for that. That being said they would be overpaying as their side adds up to 2 09 rares. Keep in mind they are offering ponys which don’t have the best demand and can go for underpay . Demand is subjective so it’s up to you to determine if your happy with this trade . Personally I’d pass as that store pet has great demand .

[phxyvi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86043592&userid=967730&signature=gEM9U8SCBs2FjasZPv4M2g

Rarity wise 2014 store pets are worth a 2009 rare, haven’t seen many that will actually trade one for that. That being said they would be overpaying as their side adds up to 2 09 rares. Keep in mind they are offering ponys which don’t have the best demand and can go for underpay . Demand is subjective so it’s up to you to determine if your happy with this trade . Personally I’d pass as that store pet has great demand .

Thank you ^^ I personally want those specific ponies but wasnt sure if i could do better for my store