"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[reze]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86041773&userid=653234&signature=s1Qh2KfI4c-DqllxND1KXA

hi i really need help with this trade,, idk if it adds up to 1.5 nons? since i value my july pps at 1.5 nons

If I offered a 09 rare warrior for This pet
Would it be fair, underpay, or overpay? What would be fair?

putting this in reply here so i don’t spam - personally i’d keep the 2010 very rare because those halloween cats are much harder to find, whereas rare warriors aren’t as hard to find in comparison. it’s also worth noting that the rare warriors had extended releases to 2010 and in the end it’s your choice how to value them .

[Demonking Urizen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86041773&userid=653234&signature=s1Qh2KfI4c-DqllxND1KXA

hi i really need help with this trade,, idk if it adds up to 1.5 nons? since i value my july pps at 1.5 nons

Considering the Pot's value fluctuates much and seems to go for a Non only with patience this trade is unfair to the July PPS as the rest doesn't add up to a Sorb, even with the demand of the old store pets.

[reze]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86042997&userid=653234&signature=0SZrIMiEtrdJruTgkYayIA

thanks for the help before! they added this, i don’t know if it’s much of an add, but if not, what would have to be added to make it fair?

[snufcin]

which of these bids would be best for these items?

bid 1
bid 2

i like both bids but bid 1 is the most tempting! any thoughts?

[Demonking Urizen]

which of these bids would be best for these items?

bid 1
bid 2

i like both bids but bid 1 is the most tempting! any thoughts?

Considering the relative poor demand of the Pink Septembers and the good demand of the July Lioness I would definitely go for the first bid.

[acronymm]

which of these bids would be best for these items?

bid 1
bid 2

i like both bids but bid 1 is the most tempting! any thoughts?

Considering the relative poor demand of the Pink Septembers and the good demand of the July Lioness I would definitely go for the first bid.

Agreed! A lovely offer there.

[snufcin]

which of these bids would be best for these items?

bid 1
bid 2

i like both bids but bid 1 is the most tempting! any thoughts?

Considering the relative poor demand of the Pink Septembers and the good demand of the July Lioness I would definitely go for the first bid.

awesome, thank you!

[Demonking Urizen]

So I'm trying to trade down my Winged Blood Dog;
offer 1
offer 2
which one is looking better?

plus, what do you think about this trade, considering demand?

thank you

[mintfrogs]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86027173&userid=635867&signature=Y3w0gM29-c4nsY_UU7p4WA
thanks

[acronymm]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86027173&userid=635867&signature=Y3w0gM29-c4nsY_UU7p4WA
thanks

Personally, I'd accept that. The items are newer.