"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[maisie+flokez]

Just been offered this. Probably planning on editing, but what is one UR Aussie/Cookie worth and what's its demand like?

[Anteat.er]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85521487&userid=882276&signature=EDy_JL1Dr4DFsLJQCA3KRw
Unsure :'O someone please help!!!

[Smaug The Dragon]

I can't be even more tempted with this trade. What are both demands worth?? The Zonkey is a TRUEDATE. I'm only looking for demand!
P.S. Thank you so much for the offer, Fortune, you're too sweet! x) <3

[amarok.]

Just been offered this. Probably planning on editing, but what is one UR Aussie/Cookie worth and what's its demand like?

Rarity wise, the Aussies are almost fair swaps for the tribal/toxics/sorbet, since the UR Aussie is in roughly the same ballpark rarity wise as far as we can tell. Therefore this would be very unfair to you. The nonjewel and Ur foal would need to be removed from your side.

Despite bad demand claims, it's not generally that widely disliked. People just don't like to trade for pets they think they won't be able to get rid of again, and once you label something as "bad demand" (correctly or not) the label tends to stick. Similarly demand is incredibly fickle and changes all too quickly. It might be hard to trade but I'd also like to add that toxics are also a nightmare to trade unfortunately. In that respect I don't think you're worse off with the Aussies, since they at least solidly trade for overpay, technically.

Demand wise, the aussie fetches a solid 1 non, occasionally up to 1.5 nons depending on the user. As such it's fair for your side, assuming 2 sorbets equal a non. The Ur foal goes for 1-1.5 nons and the nonjewel fetches 1. Pretty square, though if you value your foal at 1.5 they'll need to add something along the lines of a sorbet.

Personally, I wouldn't take it due to how unfair it would be rarity wise, but demand wise it definitely is fair. It largely depends on how you value your pets.

[Smaug The Dragon]

I can't be even more tempted with this trade. What are both demands worth?? The Zonkey is a TRUEDATE. I'm only looking for demand!
P.S. Thank you so much for the offer, Fortune, you're too sweet! x) <3

their side is 4.5-5 nons - here’s why

valuing the zonkey at 2, liontail at 2.5, that makes 4.5 - the liontail can and has pushed 3 nons, so valuing it at 3, it would be 5

the cerb usually settles for 3-3.5 so i find them rly over

Could I possibly snag a few more opinions due to demand?

[CedarShrooms]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=86013079&userid=970813&signature=-aXQJ2iCVIf0TXtlzJKFBg
Is this fair? I don't feel like it is but I wanted another opinion

[TheRubyDragon]

How does this plus this look as a bid for my Flop Blood Dog?

A Flop Blood Dog is worth 6 - 7 mixed '09 rares, so they're overpay with both bids together

Thank you for the quick response!

[amarok.]

I can't be even more tempted with this trade. What are both demands worth?? The Zonkey is a TRUEDATE. I'm only looking for demand!
P.S. Thank you so much for the offer, Fortune, you're too sweet! x) <3

their side is 4.5-5 nons - here’s why

valuing the zonkey at 2, liontail at 2.5, that makes 4.5 - the liontail can and has pushed 3 nons, so valuing it at 3, it would be 5

the cerb usually settles for 3-3.5 so i find them rly over

Could I possibly snag a few more opinions due to demand?

they're insanely far over rarity wise, and arguably very over demand wise as well. even in the worst case scenario where the lt "only" fetches 2 nons, that's still 4 nons total.

[sydneydf]

Thoughts on this bid for 17 2010 rare warrior cats?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=86008725&userid=72526&signature=Cr8N7qZwjCaFTk_CHix-Hw

[medusa]

is this fair? thanks! :)