"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[Rhiley]

Item trade, any thoughts? Thank you!

[boundin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85972529&userid=931505&signature=ZDQWEzcnJUns3GpJGZVpBw
Does this look fair?

[Rbpuppy]

is this fair? how much does the GWJ go for and does it have good demand?

The GWJ goes for about a Non or 2-3 sorbets. The Bengal goes for 1-2 Nons. Personally with demand in mind I wouldn’t take it, especially since you can get more for the bengal.

[amarok.]

is this fair? how much does the GWJ go for and does it have good demand?

The GWJ goes for about a Non or 2-3 sorbets. The Bengal goes for 1-2 Nons. Personally with demand in mind I wouldn’t take it, especially since you can get more for the bengal.

*But, to answer your question, it is fair.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85972529&userid=931505&signature=ZDQWEzcnJUns3GpJGZVpBw
Does this look fair?

By the 2:1 rule they'd be overpaying by a fair bit, but bear in mind that a lot of people no longer follow that mentality exactly and that quantity has its own value, too. I'd personally call it about square but it really depends on how to value your quantity and whether you're willing to part with it for one pet. The bettas can be hard to find so if you want this particular pet for your collection, it might well be worth it, but that's a lot of pets to part with in exchange.

[luisa]

Is this fair?

Thank you for any help <3

[Katsumi-Luna]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85981875&userid=26641&signature=XUcRrTdBx8bS4EMb-AL6ow

would this be a fair swap? also I'm not the only one that finds their trading partner goes offline as soon as I've sent a beefy trade like this?

[CalicoWolf]

This is the only bid I got:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85980220&userid=6076&signature=j9_sBtdX6RTh6JQQdbsu-Q
Is it fair?

[Katsumi-Luna]

This is the only bid I got:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85980220&userid=6076&signature=j9_sBtdX6RTh6JQQdbsu-Q
Is it fair?

No, The RBM goes for a non and the Rabbit goes for a sorbet from what I've seen

[Rbpuppy]

This is the only bid I got:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85980220&userid=6076&signature=j9_sBtdX6RTh6JQQdbsu-Q
Is it fair?

No, The RBM goes for a non and the Rabbit goes for a sorbet from what I've seen

Actually the rabbit is valued at about a Non or 2-3 sorbets, while the horse is valued at a Non. So it’s a fair swap once you take off the extra pet from their side.

[lukas_stop]

light speckled rat + ? = '09 ur dog?
I know the rat has bad demand but what would be needed to close the gap?