"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[awful things]

Can I get some help with this trade?
Thank you xx

[Boneabii]

Hey guys! Any advice on this trade? Trade
Here's what I traded for my cerb: Trade
I'm really reluctant to trade the cerberus off, because not only did I just finally get it a few days ago, but I'm also trying to complete the Cerb set so I can auction it off.
Any and all help is appreciated! ♥

They're offering about 8 nons, and the Cerb is worth 7-7.5, from what I've seen, so I'd say this is fair, if not a non's worth of overpay.

[Bear-sama]

]Hi! Is this fair? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85759645&userid=811862&signature=AUex5D3ZyInDvHAFecz5dA

[wingsofsilver]

For growing white dragon?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85755306&userid=309172&signature=276sYtU261W1t1ShQ2Z6cQ

if you still go by the list, the malk white
dragon is worth 38-50 '09 rares. in this
case i'd say it would be slightly unfair
to them as the gryphon store pets have
been going for september lists. get a
second opinion though.

Thanks! Second opinion?

[Boneabii]

]Hi! Is this fair? Thanks in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85759645&userid=811862&signature=AUex5D3ZyInDvHAFecz5dA

Overpay on their side. To make it fair, take out the 2011 rare on their side. All those 2016 rares only added up to a 2013.

[crypticscreams]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764330&userid=753157&signature=rH6n8Q4x7-8UuDq2aNxy7Q
How fair do you think this is due to how much people like the baby cheetah ?

[MysticalDragonDog]

Would this be fair?:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764362&userid=686260&signature=EJ8sB8EA0lJnAWBbzFwZbw

Rarity value-wise I'd say it's fair, but demand value-wise I've seen that dragon get traded for so much more, sometimes even "list"/UR pets.

[Carolyn]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764330&userid=753157&signature=rH6n8Q4x7-8UuDq2aNxy7Q
How fair do you think this is due to how much people like the baby cheetah ?

I traded for mine yesterday and it was a lottttt less :https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85742209&userid=659538&signature=HNtwu6p87vGyCzJMj-5PxA

I would accept

[amarok.]

Would this be fair?:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764362&userid=686260&signature=EJ8sB8EA0lJnAWBbzFwZbw

Rarity value-wise I'd say it's fair, but demand value-wise I've seen that dragon get traded for so much more, sometimes even "list"/UR pets.

I'm not trying to be funny but the PPS dragon cat fad is pretty much over at this point and they're currently going for mid advents to septembers or are sprinkled into already fair trades. There's one or two out there who still value them at mainlists but most of the people I speak to think that's ridiculous. Considering that of the two the kitsune is probably the more popular of the two and can also comfortably fetch a mid advent, this would be fair demand wise.
Rarity wise, the kitsune is overpay by 1 '09 rare.

[Boneabii]

Would this be fair?:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85764362&userid=686260&signature=EJ8sB8EA0lJnAWBbzFwZbw

Rarity value-wise I'd say it's fair, but demand value-wise I've seen that dragon get traded for so much more, sometimes even "list"/UR pets.

I'm not trying to be funny but the PPS dragon cat fad is pretty much over at this point and they're currently going for mid advents or are sprinkled into already fair trades. Considering that of the two the kitsune is probably the more popular of the two and can also comfortably fetch a mid advent, this would be fair demand wise.
Rarity wise, the kitsune is overpay by 1 '09 rare.

agreed