"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[snowdrake]

they sent a new offer!
I actually really like this but I have no idea if it's fair? is it true that a whole set of warrior cats trades for a non or was that just a one time thing? I'm really tempted aaaaaaaah

edit: lmao it appears that we all get the same offer from the same person xD

[.dylan.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85751227&userid=673904&signature=7Utrqu17uIvrpICM9qfBtg i got this auction bid, i love the pets but not sure if the worth is the same. help?

[amarok.]

they sent a new offer!
I actually really like this but I have no idea if it's fair? is it true that a whole set of warrior cats trades for a non or was that just a one time thing? I'm really tempted aaaaaaaah

edit: lmao it appears that we all get the same offer from the same person xD

@everybody offered a warrior set, cba to find and quite everybody tbh.

Having had a brief skim through some forums I can't actually see a trade where the full set went for a non recently, so I would imagine that was a one time thing people just keep parroting, but if any lurkers do happen to have links I'd love to seem them.

That aside, the BEG has peculiar demand at best, fetches 1-1.5 nons and rarity wise is worth roughly the same as a sorbet dog.

I *have* seen the set trade for a sorbet a few times, so I'd personally say they're underpaying, especially when the full set is only work a couple of mid advents and only trades for varyingly large sums due to demand whereas, whilst it's also not quite worth a non, at least the BEG does have an established "demand value" of above a non. This would be really subjective so get a few more opinions, but to put it bluntly you'll really have to decide this one for yourself.

[GhostFaceッ]

should i take plain + grevy's zerba for UR tess cat? help
i heard the zebras are hard to trade off

[:-(]

hi! ive received more offers for my auction. may i know the fairness of these two bids individually ;;
bid 1
bid 2
thanks so much in advance ;-;

[delete myaccount]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85746785&userid=122180&signature=2-ufa7gvLpIOvlERrZdRmg
can someone help me with this?

please help us to make this fair

we would love to get an answer!

[carnivorous.]

hello! i'm trying to work out a trade but i'm a little rusty when it comes to quantity, and some help would be appreciated! thank you!

[dillydallydarlene]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85743437&userid=47800&signature=TL9Moop98h2B32azbfw47w

What would make this fair? They want the 4 apps dogs on my side

What on their side would make this fair?

[mushroomish]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85741322&userid=978329&signature=bPUko6nscppbs6zvBICAVA

i've been asking for about 100 pages... can someone please look at this?

[Deathwing]

is this fair? i dont want to cheat them out of cs