"Is this a fair trade?" Thread [Updated Dec 2019]

[pigeon -]

how does this look?

i wouldn't, i've seen too many people trade the unickorn for a sorb out of sheer frustration

not only that but this would be unfair rarity wise. whilst the unickorn is incredibly valuable, it comes second to the zebras.

thank you, its a bid for an auction, but it's the only one so just wanted to see it's fairness in case it stays the only one c:

[epicinium]

grevy's zebra for joker bun?

[Melanga ♡]

grevy's zebra for joker bun?

In my opinion, this is massive overpay on their side rarity-wise. On the ex list, Grevy's zebra is above the gap and quite high on the main list and the Joker bun is below the gap. While the Joker bun has good demand, I don't think it's close to making the trade fair. If I'm going by more recent terms, the zebra equals 1-2 nons and the Joker bun isn't even worth a sorb (but someone please correct me if I'm wrong).

Keep in mind that zebras are incredibly difficult to trade off for their actual worth. A lot of people struggle with getting just one non for it. Like I mentioned before, you would be getting a pretty good deal, but there's a chance that you could get stuck with the zebra for quite some time, if you're willing to take the risk.

Some people might view this differently, so feel free to get a second opinion!

[amarok.]

grevy's zebra for joker bun?

In my opinion, this is massive overpay on their side rarity-wise. On the ex list, Grevy's zebra is above the gap and quite high on the main list and the Joker bun is below the gap. While the Joker bun has good demand, I don't think it's close to making the trade fair. If I'm going by more recent terms, the zebra equals 1-2 nons and the Joker bun isn't even worth a sorb (but someone please correct me if I'm wrong).

Keep in mind that zebras are incredibly difficult to trade off for their actual worth. A lot of people struggle with getting just one non for it. Like I mentioned before, you would be getting a pretty good deal, but there's a chance that you could get stuck with the zebra for quite some time, if you're willing to take the risk.

Some people might view this differently, so feel free to get a second opinion!

the joker bun is worth a lot more than a sorb. please be careful. you're getting confused with the joker dog, which is not worth a sorbet.

[Luxio]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85728871&userid=672119&signature=ZmUdRgkPb1qkIT4OANTmKg
How about this for a warrior cat?

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85728871&userid=672119&signature=ZmUdRgkPb1qkIT4OANTmKg
How about this for a warrior cat?

They're overpaying by a lot, since your cat is only worth an early '10 rare and as such ~30 c$ would be fair. Demand is up to you.

[Melanga ♡]

grevy's zebra for joker bun?

In my opinion, this is massive overpay on their side rarity-wise. On the ex list, Grevy's zebra is above the gap and quite high on the main list and the Joker bun is below the gap. While the Joker bun has good demand, I don't think it's close to making the trade fair. If I'm going by more recent terms, the zebra equals 1-2 nons and the Joker bun isn't even worth a sorb (but someone please correct me if I'm wrong).

Keep in mind that zebras are incredibly difficult to trade off for their actual worth. A lot of people struggle with getting just one non for it. Like I mentioned before, you would be getting a pretty good deal, but there's a chance that you could get stuck with the zebra for quite some time, if you're willing to take the risk.

Some people might view this differently, so feel free to get a second opinion!

the joker bun is worth a lot more than a sorb. please be careful. you're getting confused with the joker dog, which is not worth a sorbet.

yes, thank you for pointing that out ^^

(this is irrelevant now but the Joker bun wasn't placed correctly on the list so just disregard all the stuff I said earlier)

It goes for 1-1.5 nons. It doesn't have great demand, either, so it just depends on which pet you prefer.

[epicinium]

grevy's zebra for joker bun?

In my opinion, this is massive overpay on their side rarity-wise. On the ex list, Grevy's zebra is above the gap and quite high on the main list and the Joker bun is below the gap. While the Joker bun has good demand, I don't think it's close to making the trade fair. If I'm going by more recent terms, the zebra equals 1-2 nons and the Joker bun isn't even worth a sorb (but someone please correct me if I'm wrong).

Keep in mind that zebras are incredibly difficult to trade off for their actual worth. A lot of people struggle with getting just one non for it. Like I mentioned before, you would be getting a pretty good deal, but there's a chance that you could get stuck with the zebra for quite some time, if you're willing to take the risk.

Some people might view this differently, so feel free to get a second opinion!

the joker bun is worth a lot more than a sorb. please be careful. you're getting confused with the joker dog, which is not worth a sorbet.

I'm not a huge fan of either of them qwq thank you both so much, though!

[Luxio]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85728871&userid=672119&signature=ZmUdRgkPb1qkIT4OANTmKg
How about this for a warrior cat?

They're overpaying by a lot, since your cat is only worth an early '10 rare and as such ~30 c$ would be fair. Demand is up to you.

Okay thank you!

[EchothroughDarkness]

Was this trade fair??

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85720525&userid=410864&signature=EWGESmFn45yLyharRHQYoA

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85730375&userid=410864&signature=SK2kihYd-RjpA6h-EGUxCw