[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[RiverRaven]

Dogtag for joker
Vs
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85505627&userid=686698&signature=H9xAcMKO9i30Ruv6VaT8MA
Their both overpay but which would be a better offer?

Dogtag Is about 2 none imo? 1.5 I suppose if we want to push it
The foal is 1.5 and the squid I would count on settling at 1

Either trade is ridiculous overpay for a joker, barely a non. I would ask your trading partners if they know what they're doing and they're sure

Both are bids in a auction, both trading partners very clearly know what their doing. The Joker ranges from 1-2 non depending on the buyer and trader and the fluctuation of demand.
Can I get a second opinion?

[soyroberta]

help needed :^)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85525989&userid=783019&signature=7Fsu3EH7e4DE6XK8-tbzSw

[mushroomish]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85527648&userid=601208&signature=_XKka8ivSDx7bDtUuCoJeQ
what would need to be added to make this fair? i know the apple's demand is terrible....

I would keep my sorb puppy. It could turn into a pink one, and be worth a non. In the case of that happening this would be very unfair to you. It is best to wait[/quote]

agree! the apple isn't really worth it at all, i had one and no one wanted to trade for anywhere near its supposed worth. it prob shouldnt be considered a list anymore tbh

[phxyvi]

help needed :^)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85525989&userid=783019&signature=7Fsu3EH7e4DE6XK8-tbzSw

Neither have assigned rarities and were released at the same time. Should be a fair swap though I think the cup is more sought after right now.

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85528294&userid=290196&signature=6gQtlkCBuaFXrTcyHnhgSQ

Not good with item trades, anyone help?

[phxyvi]

gtag for joker
Vs
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85505627&userid=686698&signature=H9xAcMKO9i30Ruv6VaT8MA
Their both overpay but which would be a better offer?[/quote][/quote]

Dogtag Is about 2 none imo? 1.5 I suppose if we want to push it
The foal is 1.5 and the squid I would count on settling at 1

Either trade is ridiculous overpay for a joker, barely a non. I would ask your trading partners if they know what they're doing and they're sure[/quote]
Both are bids in a auction, both trading partners very clearly know what their doing. The Joker ranges from 1-2 non depending on the buyer and trader and the fluctuation of demand.
Can I get a second opinion?[/quote]




Alright ^^ well. You asked for advice and I gave it, I apologize you disagree with the joker's general value. I didnt mean to offend you in advising you to talk to your trading partner. whenever a trade is particularly over, it is always best to ensure your partner knows what their doing. Not required but certainly courteous. Being auction offers does not exclude them from being uneducated on a pet whatsoever and I'd rather not let anyone get scooped out of their pets by simply not knowing.

But as stated, you could always not do that. They did offer and itd hardly make you a scammer to take them

[Nia]

back again lol - is this trade fair? tysm to anyone who replies!

[turnip_soup]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85483901&userid=966226&signature=K5fbax4MZEKmyzpMxEhQCA
Help me please

[phxyvi]

back again lol - is this trade fair? tysm to anyone who replies!

Rarity wise you're over, however, the dragoncat has jingly demand. And so, it often catches trades several times its value. Taking that into the consideration you will likely need to add a lot if you want to realistically make an attempt at a dragoncat

[eufemia]

1. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85519378&userid=978798&signature=Or7YaNMuSaOPCIk_cUJ42A
2. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85519408&userid=978798&signature=P-Dkg2nrdLUBbJ4PhREKAQ

Are either of these fair?