[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[snowdrake]

Can I pretty please get some help >.< Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85425994&userid=811862&signature=0GEjd8e5CvLaMBOMisrH9g

very unfair to the 2010 rares. your side only adds up to a little more than 1.5 2015 rares!

[maisie+flokez]

i know the cup doesnt have a set value yet but hows this trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450036&userid=623530&signature=-nZHu6OzLHHuONThAJALxg

Up to you as to what you personally value the cup, but it's likely to end up at 1-1.5 nons after the 18th hype dies down, whereas the dogtag fetches 2 nons (can be up to 3 nons, but it's demand has dipped), plus the advent and September. My opinion is they're definitely overpaying and it seems like a good offer.

[snowdrake]

i know the cup doesnt have a set value yet but hows this trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450036&userid=623530&signature=-nZHu6OzLHHuONThAJALxg

Up to you as to what you personally value the cup, but it's likely to end up at 1-1.5 nons after the 18th hype dies down, whereas the dogtag fetches 2 nons (can be up to 3 nons, but it's demand has dipped), plus the advent and September. My opinion is they're definitely overpaying and it seems like a good offer.

I agree. it's only a matter of time until people will start offering less.

[Maeja]

i know the cup doesnt have a set value yet but hows this trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450036&userid=623530&signature=-nZHu6OzLHHuONThAJALxg

Up to you as to what you personally value the cup, but it's likely to end up at 1-1.5 nons after the 18th hype dies down, whereas the dogtag fetches 2 nons (can be up to 3 nons, but it's demand has dipped), plus the advent and September. My opinion is they're definitely overpaying and it seems like a good offer.

I agree. it's only a matter of time until people will start offering less.

thank you guys.
i also really want the bee but im not sure if this is worth it, im aware that the list isnt a thing anymore but im just not sure trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450220&userid=623530&signature=n-iAlmAGym67DQ-xqQ9bpQ

[Asvoria]

I would like some help with this trade please: link

I wouldn't! The holly dog only tends to go for a non sometimes a non and a half whereas the dog tag is worth a lot more!

Would like a second opinion! If they added a BEG on their side, would it make a difference?

[boston]

thank you guys.
i also really want the bee but im not sure if this is worth it, im aware that the list isnt a thing anymore but im just not sure trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450220&userid=623530&signature=n-iAlmAGym67DQ-xqQ9bpQ

The raven alone can go for two nons; I would say you’re overpaying.

[maisie+flokez]

Up to you as to what you personally value the cup, but it's likely to end up at 1-1.5 nons after the 18th hype dies down, whereas the dogtag fetches 2 nons (can be up to 3 nons, but it's demand has dipped), plus the advent and September. My opinion is they're definitely overpaying and it seems like a good offer.

I agree. it's only a matter of time until people will start offering less.

thank you guys.
i also really want the bee but im not sure if this is worth it, im aware that the list isnt a thing anymore but im just not sure trades/viewtrade.php?id=85450220&userid=623530&signature=n-iAlmAGym67DQ-xqQ9bpQ

I wouldn't trade that. The bee's going for around 2 nons at the moment, the raven is 1.5-2 nons and the punk is around a sorbet at the moment (so your side is worth 2-2.5 nons), but the demand for them is rising. Store pet worth is going to keep increasing so I think you could get more for the raven & the punk than just a bee.

[maisie+flokez]

I would like some help with this trade please: link

I wouldn't! The holly dog only tends to go for a non sometimes a non and a half whereas the dog tag is worth a lot more!

Would like a second opinion! If they added a BEG on their side, would it make a difference?

Yeah that'd make it much more fair. Holly dog is 1-1.5 nons (closer to 1 non at the moment though) and BEG is 1-1.5 nons, so 2-3 nons overall, and the dogtag goes for at least 2, but up to 3 nons (although its demand has dipped recently). So it depends on what you and your trading partner value the holly & BEG at, but if around 2-2.5 nons then fair

[smartiez]

does the cat have more demand due to sitting cat or is it just fair? I might just keep my dog because i like the litter though.

[lullaby]

does the cat have more demand due to sitting cat or is it just fair? I might just keep my dog because i like the litter though.

it’s fair! though the cat has no extra demand!