Is this a Fair Trade? (Dec 18th edition)

[Fragmented]

Hello! I really need some help on this trade, though it does involve a dec 18th pet from last year. I was wondering what kinds of pets would be a great addition to the trade to make it fair? Any advice is really helpful, thank you for all your time!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85416019&userid=834185&signature=9nwUkBno2eKVe7R_a1m0vw

^^

[BonBon<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85433019&userid=967332&signature=8FesJ7_8hlr_3fQD57kFYw

Fair?

[ooo]

I still and always will follow list values, though it was discontinued. That being said, how does this look?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85439554&userid=937414&signature=ZuKAnCBkhUOs82fh9oq3Wg

[IcedCoffeez]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85438316&userid=790015&signature=vjapoX2Vv8CPzD5zTByM5w
Opinions?

[Midori Ookami]

I'm just curious about whether or not this trade is fair.

1900C$ for my moonswirl(I think that's what people have been calling it) pup?



I'm not sure that I'm interested in trading it for C$, but I want to know if the value of the trade itself is fair or not? Thanks ^^

[Ishuna]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85423148

Help? Not sure how much this ur cat is worth!

[Darkmoons]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85424146&userid=489300&signature=k2toBmit6C-1gmLQ09z1Yw

How about this?

[hiimbee10]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85423148

Help? Not sure how much this ur cat is worth!

Wrong link .w.

[fiirstcrush]

i've been away for a while so honestly i have no idea for rarities, worth, value, etc. anymore so just wondering if any of these are fair? thank you so much if anyone can help xx ♡

one
-
two

[Namjoon lover]

ids this a fair trade i know this in an '08 vr but i not sure it is fair trades/viewtrade.php?id=85419994&userid=976154&signature=-a7sM6OUDGdc5NIlSFWjxA