[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[Webbers]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85342842&userid=317104&signature=atylFSqUCivEKFTLHQ_a8w
Is this a fair trade?..

[Doberman Pinscher]

If someone could help me figure out some of these bids, I’d be super thankful.
Which one seems the best?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85267433&userid=169112&signature=q5Elvzr1Ile48dRlWByk8w

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85296312&userid=169112&signature=Lzg036rBhQkIXHQ8OL99HQ

To me, the second bid seems like a good one. They’re offering another pet from the same tier on the Old advent list, with a not too bad demand, as well as the sitting cat and added rares. I’d get another opinion on the first trade though, as im not sure about dealing with C$ X

Thank you!! I’d love one more opinion if anyone wants to chip in ❤️

[leek]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85305276&userid=811478&signature=RXkcYemzUGnNLh_jlgIyMQ

is this fair? I just got back on cs and idk rarities HAHA

please i need answers!

whoever helps gets a gift! <3

the rules state you can't mention gifts or it will encourage false answers. however despite that this trade seems fair. 2017 store pets go for an early 2010 rare

[*AlpacaBella*]

I mean I'm 90% sure it's unfair but I have no idea what my cat is worth XD

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85330458&userid=109598&signature=Fvk8dLQrk5x6Zck9c6Yvtg

[amarok.]

I’ve been here before with this trade but they’ve sent it again and I’d like more opinions on it since last time, it got really confusing and mixed up and I ended up canceling because I was really confused. Please, if you’re going to provide an answer make it clear and don’t give conflicting opinions, it confuses me badly.

The Unickorn is extremely rare. As you can see from the OMGSR rarity list on this thread (halfway down page), it's probably one of the rarest pets on the site, but it's not recognised as such and has bad demand. However, it's worth at least a non, so it could definitely trade for more than the purple toxic if you found the right person to trade it to. Toxics have variable demand, but I believe the purple toxic is currently going for around a sorbet. Nons can go for 2-3 sorbets, so the unicorn is worth a LOT more and it's unfair to the unicorn side. Hope that helps

i've already chipped in with my opinion and maisie has just confirmed everything i've said the first time around but essentially you've had 3~ users telling you it's overpay on their side as compared to just one who said otherwise because the unickorn has poor demand, but to be frank toxics aren't exactly popular either and at their best will fetch half of what the uni consistently fetches.

edit; i'd also like to add that i've personally never seen a nick uni go for a sorbet before and haven't actually heard of it happening either, besides the ridiculous demand value of "sorb-non" that gets passed around. considering an ur tiger, worth considerably less than the uni, fetches 5-6 nons these days i think that's absolutely insane.

the thing is, you're going to get conflicting opinions anyway these days because demand is extremely controversial at this point and there are users on both sides helping out here. it's much better that you have all the information and not just biased information from one side or the other so you can make a more informed choice.

[Minaethiel]

This one?

[url=https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85341371&userid=322&signature=dauQGJ6Jg0dr490MHgmd5A]And this one too?]

And how much would a Red Android + Woodwing need ro add for a UR Lion?

Sorry for all the questions ;^-^

[HennesseyCamaro]

Cheshire Cat and the 3 BW group what can that trade for? The cat has high demand I know that but is is possible to get a sorbet or non?

[aurobruh]

nvm oopsie

[MMagpie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85343011&userid=941534&signature=706RLRStp-b1moM3hnviTw

Is this fair?

[Gelée Nova]

Hi! Could I get anyone's opinion on this trade? Is there any demand I'd need to consider as well? I've gotten a few trades for this dog (along with other dogs in the litter)- Any help is appreciated!
Thank you <3