[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[uro]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85104056&userid=741998&signature=wUYjsqEqDYF3ki3bQkbNNA

help?

any second opinions? I'm conflicted because the guinea does have pretty good demand and it's a VR

[DitsyDruid]

Is this fair? I’m not sure rarity and demand wise
Click me!

If you follow the list that horse is worth 4-5 09 rares so it'd be unfair to you're trade partner. If you don't follow the list it would be pretty close to fair as each of your store pets are worth a 2010 rare each and 2008 VR are worth 2 09 rares and a 2010 rare. You might keep in mind that tess horses seem to be a bit tricky to trade off.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85104056&userid=741998&signature=wUYjsqEqDYF3ki3bQkbNNA

help?

any second opinions? I'm conflicted because the guinea does have pretty good demand and it's a VR

You'd be overpaying. That guinea pig is from 2010 so it's only worth a 09 rare while you're offering 3 09 rares and quite a few items with decent demand. However it's up to you on how you'd like to factor in demand but I personally wouldn't pay that much.

[marmoris]

xx should i accept this? thank you in advance.

[Oscurio]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85094990&userid=711966&signature=jBif4nDrn3IjoJGsZz_3pg

is this fair? need advice on rarity and demand thanks!

not sure about demand wise. but by rarity its unfair. both dogs are from 2008 and the cat is from 2009 and zodiac is true date. the 40C$ would only make up another '09 VR. 2 '09 VR's is worth one, but the zodiac doesn't make it fair to add the second one

second opinions?

[Ironic Equation]

xx should i accept this? thank you in advance.

Personally I wouldn't since moonswirl demand is a little 'iffy' at the moment. They seem to be getting 2-3 nons, while patchworks are getting a solid 1.5 or maybe slightly less. A lot of people don't like trading stores for non-stores too. If you want a moonswirl though this trade is in the range of fair, but you could probably get more for the patchies.

[marmoris]

xx should i accept this? thank you in advance.

Personally I wouldn't since moonswirl demand is a little 'iffy' at the moment. They seem to be getting 2-3 nons, while patchworks are getting a solid 1.5 or maybe slightly less. A lot of people don't like trading stores for non-stores too. If you want a moonswirl though this trade is in the range of fair, but you could probably get more for the patchies.

thank you! i think i will pass then as the moonswirl is not a priority pet.

[DitsyDruid]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85094990&userid=711966&signature=jBif4nDrn3IjoJGsZz_3pg

is this fair? need advice on rarity and demand thanks!

not sure about demand wise. but by rarity its unfair. both dogs are from 2008 and the cat is from 2009 and zodiac is true date. the 40C$ would only make up another '09 VR. 2 '09 VR's is worth one, but the zodiac doesn't make it fair to add the second one

second opinions?

Agreed, It's unfair rarity wise but only slightly. Many users value 2008 VR's at 2 09 rares and a 09 uncommon or 2010 rare. So your side adds up to 5 09 rares and you're partners side adds up to 3 09 rares and a 2010 rare or 4 09 rares and a 2010 rare. It ranges because of the C$ as 40-45C$ is worth a mid 09 rare to very rare so it depends on how you value the C$. Demand is up to you and your trade partner.

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

I need some opinions on the following trades please and thank you!!

Trade #1
Trade #2
Trade #3
Trade #4

Thank you so much to anyone who helps me out!!

[CookieButterLatte]

Would this be fair for both of us? Three warriors for 150c$? Thank you in advance <3

[Ironic Equation]

I need some opinions on the following trades please and thank you!!

Trade #1
Trade #2
Trade #3
Trade #4

Thank you so much to anyone who helps me out!!

1. I wouldn't personally. I generally see the liontail get 2 nons, maybe a bit more. The cerb I see get 3-4 easily. I don't feel like the store pets fill the gap, although you probably could get overpay for that quantity with current demand, so if you want to wait for a really good offer for them it could be worth it. Rarity wise the liontail is probably rarer, but even the OMG so rare ones don't go for any more demand wise.

2. I see that as unfair to the dragon. Their side has some nice high demand pets, but I've traded dragons for 1.5 nons worth consistently and I don't see them as adding up to any more than a sorbet at the absolute most, probably a mid main list.

3. Looks relatively fair valuing the cerb at 3 nons, marionette at 1.5, yellow android at 0.5 and green android at 1. Not a bad offer, although I'd personally keep the cerb since I have seen them get more with that crazy demand.

4. Seems like overpay on your side. The cerb gets 3-4 nons and the patchwork and dragon get about 1.5 each. That's 6-7 nons, and generally I only see the eat me get 5, although it's demand has been rising lately.

Hope this helps!