[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

I need some opinions on the following trades please and thank you!!

Trade #1
Trade #2
Trade #3

I was told that Animal Egg #4 is worth a non but I don't know how accurate that is. Do items like that have demand or not really?

Thank you so much to anyone who helps me out!!

[amarok.]

Which bid is the best? And which would you take??
Bid 2
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 9
Bid 10
Bid 11

I'd personally choose the zebra bid, it's much rarer than the pink sorbet and has been omgsr longer, it's demand sits at about 1-1.5 nons as well so it's of equal demand value. I'm unsure of the others, but none of them quite have the demand or rarity factor to rival the zebra.

Thank you. Second opinion??

i'd absolutely agree. rarity wise, zebras are some of the most valuable pets on the site, but they do have poor demand and usually only go for a fraction of what they're worth, unfortunately (~1 non these days).
the offer with the ur aussie has potential to go for more (1-1.5 nons) and has marginally better demand, but i'd agree with taking the zebra because i think people are realising trading purely by demand is unsustainable and the market value for zebras will eventually increase again. get another opinion here though.

[bloodborne (2015)]

how's this?

very slight underpay on their side. there's half a year between the dates so i'd personally say they need to add another '09 rare to their side. if you're not as pedantic about dates, it's very roughly a straight swap but i'd also like to add that the gsd has good demand and you might find better offers. c;

thankyou!

[Ironic Equation]

how's this?

very slight underpay on their side. there's half a year between the dates so i'd personally say they need to add another '09 rare to their side. if you're not as pedantic about dates, it's very roughly a straight swap but i'd also like to add that the gsd has good demand and you might find better offers. c;

thankyou!

However I personally disagree and would say the other side is overpaying as the emerald bwolf was on the retired Rares list and was worth 4-5 Mixed 09 Rares + an 09 Uncommon. If you don't go by the ex-list then it would be slightly unfair to you by the three month rule.

[amarok.]

how's this?

very slight underpay on their side. there's half a year between the dates so i'd personally say they need to add another '09 rare to their side. if you're not as pedantic about dates, it's very roughly a straight swap but i'd also like to add that the gsd has good demand and you might find better offers. c;

thankyou!

However I personally disagree and would say the other side is overpaying as the emerald bwolf was on the retired Rares list and was worth 4-5 Mixed 09 Rares + an 09 Uncommon. If you don't go by the ex-list then it would be slightly unfair to you by the three month rule.

ah. apologies there. i didn't recognise the flutterboi so made the assumption he wasn't a list. thanks for the correction!

[INDIG0]

Which bid is the best? And which would you take??
Bid 2
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 9
Bid 10
Bid 11

I'd personally choose the zebra bid, it's much rarer than the pink sorbet and has been omgsr longer, it's demand sits at about 1-1.5 nons as well so it's of equal demand value. I'm unsure of the others, but none of them quite have the demand or rarity factor to rival the zebra.

i'd absolutely agree. rarity wise, zebras are some of the most valuable pets on the site, but they do have poor demand and usually only go for a fraction of what they're worth, unfortunately (~1 non these days).
the offer with the ur aussie has potential to go for more (1-1.5 nons) and has marginally better demand, but i'd agree with taking the zebra because i think people are realising trading purely by demand is unsustainable and the market value for zebras will eventually increase again. get another opinion here though.

Thank you second opinion??

[chiamai]

Is this fair? Any help is appreciated greatly!

[cαtαstrσphe]

Is this fair? Any help is appreciated greatly!

Pink sorbet trades for about a non, both green sorbet and blue toxic trade for about a sorbet, so if 2 sorbets = 1 non then this is a good trade imo. Pink sorbet might get more, but it's unlikely.

[Spottedhyenaaa]

Can someone tell me if this is fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85097774&userid=939927&signature=GQ_MBtEVA7hVoUEwz8SCQA

[crying]

good evening everybody, I was wondering if this is a fair trade <3
Thank you to anybody that replies in advance uwu