The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nice]

rarity and demand wise?

[polyphon]

is this fair?
thanks for any help !!

and this?

[Vanrouge]

rarity and demand wise?

Incredibly unfair to them, pps easily gets a sorb, Arabian only gets a September, I'd definitely check they know how much their lion gets as they probably don't

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

Need some help with this trade please and thank you!

[fadedmoonlightt]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096429&userid=879393&signature=xJrYFMUq6FZLBkjTAI28JQ


Is this fair or should I add more older Rares to my side?

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096429&userid=879393&signature=xJrYFMUq6FZLBkjTAI28JQ


Is this fair or should I add more older Rares to my side?

Yeah, you'll need to whack another '10 rare onto your side at the least. C; the full set of store pets is worth two mid '09 rares.

[cαtαstrσphe]

Opinions?

Bad, very bad.
Raven and Sunback are both 2 nons.
Cerb is 3-4 nons, dog tag 2 nons, plus the sorb. I'd trade the cerb and sorb alone for those two.

[phxyvi]

Opinions?

Bad, very bad.
Raven and Sunback are both 2 nons.
Cerb is 3-4 nons, dog tag 2 nons, plus the sorb. I'd trade the cerb and sorb alone for those two.

I would agree it’s a bad trade, but the raven gets two nons and the sunback regularly goes for 3

The dog tag I value at 2 but it hasn’t seen many trades lately so idk
And the cerb @ three. At the least you’re over by .5-1 non

[DitsyDruid]

What about these 2? :3 Any advice on any of them is gladly accepted c:

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85095990&userid=67531&signature=F80JZ1HrdCpteq7V13a3mw

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=85096129&userid=67531&signature=EOU1k1I3lbcz9q00nCG58A

1. I personally wouldn't take this trade but depending on how you value everything this could be fair or unfair to the other person. The weretomato can get a 2010 uncommon to 09 rare, the nick balloon is worth a 2010 uncommon, and the nick cake can get a 2010 uncommon to rare. All animal eggs are worth a uncommon from their release year except for 1-4 and all the other items are worth uncommons from their release year. So your side is worth about 3.5-5.5 2010 rares or about 3 2010 rares and a 2010 uncommon to 5 2010 rares and a 2010 uncommon.

2. The other person would be overpaying. Your side adds up to about a 2010 rare at max and the only item that might be worth more than a uncommon from it's release year is the fairy and that's depends on who you're trading. At max the fairy would be worth a 2013 rare and the stars can go for a common to uncommon from 2016 each. The rest of the items are worth an uncommon from their release year.

[polyphon]

is this fair?
thanks for any help !!

and this?