The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Rbpuppy]

Is this fair? I'm having trouble with this one...

it’s either fair or top overpay depending on whether you go by the 4:1 or 2:1 jump for rarity respectively.

Sorry, could you explain a little? Which one do you think is fair as well?

The 2:1 rule is 2 uncommons = 1 Rare. The 4:1 rule is 4 uncommons = 1 Rare. This is applied to all the rarities as well but doesn’t usually include list pets or store pets since those are valued with demand as well (for example a first tier advent is valued at about 3-4 09 VRs).

If you follow that rule but also include dates, this trade is actually unfair slightly to the other person. The 2013 uncommon alone would be fair rarity wise. Demand wise I usually suggest is up to the player and what they value their pet at.

[floor.]

boop
not sure how much the arabian goes for?

2011 store pets have been going for around high advents - low sept lists, at least from personal experience and some other offers I've seen around. Do get a second opinion though!

[elnachos]

how is this looking?

any second opinions?

I don't know why others are thinking that the other side is overpaying, but It's slightly unfair to you, the C$ adds up to a spotted tribal (2 sorbets) and the gearback tribal is 1 tier lower than a sorbet. The non is worth 3 sorbets so you're overpaying by a dark leopard.[/quote]

shsjdkh any last opinions?? been asking for like 9 pages now :'0

[(◍•ᴗ•◍)]

is this fair? and this one!

[floor.]

is this fair? and this one!

Your side is a main list pet, element cats are not worth that much so it's super unfair to you. (Both links are the same btw)

[phxyvi]

could I have opinions on these 3 bids?

one
two
three

Only the sunback/Raven/BEG trade is actually fair
If you want those pets, I would take it!

The others are under by several nons

The cerb/marionette trade is only about 4 nons,
And then the Liontail is about 4 too.

[Oscurio]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85094990&userid=711966&signature=jBif4nDrn3IjoJGsZz_3pg

[phxyvi]

Would you take this?

I’m really really tempted, it’s such a solid offer and all the bulk is nice as well. Plus a pps dragon cat which is like a little low list ticket for me to cash in whenever I want

H I was just really hoping for an all-stores trade for it. Do you think the sunback and beg would swap well for store pets?

[glitter]

helppp

[avz]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85095445&userid=726844&signature=jzrKnyY0Z5qqU99ehbsE_g

any help with this one is appreciated!! c: