The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mushroomish]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85003007&userid=978329&signature=J-IhexfX687-YygCSUSmzQ

is this fair?

not a great trade, the apple is an ex list pet, the other side doesn't add up anywhere near to the value of it

which trade are you talking about, sorry? i need feedback on both

[<InsertName>]

Trying to work out a trade for a missing pet I'm in need of. Is this what the green rare dragons can go for/are going for demand wise?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85003703&userid=674735&signature=V5IAQGRrCdmrAqsKZDuNAw

[Shiranuii]

Not sure about this; but is this fair?

[quisicorazon]

Are these trades fair?
#1.
#2.

[INDIG0]

Is this fair??.....,................
I've been offered this one aswell
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85001734&userid=838891&signature=iSSc5n0rLU1uJzaooVx8xg

Can some one please help me??

[007n7]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85004484&userid=966372&signature=-Zysd8ZnaXqgOhzHtQF7yw?

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85004484&userid=966372&signature=-Zysd8ZnaXqgOhzHtQF7yw?

rarity wise you're overpay by 1 early '09 rare's worth but warriors go about that much overpay for these days anyway.

[Smaug The Dragon]

Demand please.
Are they still hard to trade off or can I get better trades fro the cerb? Or is there something to add/ switch?

[phxyvi]

hi, can I get any opinions about these bids ??
does either one add up to the amt of nons that the Drink Me is worth?

trade 1
trade 2

thank you in advance![/size]

trade one defo looks better

I'd like a second opinion?[/quote]
I wouldn’t take either of them, but would agree that trade one is better
Although the cerb has a hard time getting 3 nons, so perhaps a bit under imo

I’d value the drink me at 6 nons, and the first trade at 5 valuing the cerb generously
And the fairest isn’t even close. It’s 3 nons and some change (maybe about a sorb or more in bulk, perhaps?) counting the marionettes at their highest value

[amarok.]

Not sure about this; but is this fair?

no, i wouldn't say so. the sunjewel bun is a t6 advent if you follow the list whereas both of yours are septembers. even though the grinner has incredibly poor demand and i personally think the bunny was worth a bit more than its list placement, i absolutely wouldn't take that.