The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[lucifer morningstar]

Not good with store pets, help?

It's been 6 pages, still need help!

I believe that's unfair to them. list wise, the snowflake lion is only worth 5-6 mixed '09 rares, and I believe their side adds up to quite a bit more than that. I'd get a second opinion to be sure though.

I don’t know rarities for items, is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84945193&userid=625782&signature=9s-4bvm3XfpvPZhErk1luQ

unfair to you. the tomato alone is worth a late '10 uncommon, which is worth about 6-10 C$ according to the C$ guide, though I value it at 10 at the least due to its age and rarity. the cupcake I believe is from CS Birthday '11, so would be worth a few '11 commons or an uncommon. I'd get a second opinion to be sure though.

[>> Leafstorm515]

My partner and I are looking for more opinions (Thanks to those that replied!) on this trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84926851&userid=27907&signature=3lAP9CrrpcOjeBy__wYOIw We are both rusty with values, and I personally used the list all the other times to trade but since it is now retired I'm lost as to the value of most pets. Could we get opinions as to what the individual worth of some of the store pets involved are, and how the trade could be edited to be more fair? Thank you!

Any help appreciated!

[_.mustard._]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84935725&userid=942822&signature=WrGrBiz1BQYN7mBuxixxaw

[maisie+flokez]

Can someone please help me with this following trades?

One

Two

EDIT:

Also this? Pretty sure it's unfair but I'm not sure how the old store pet values work out, so would be grateful for an explanation!

Thank you in advance!

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84935725&userid=942822&signature=WrGrBiz1BQYN7mBuxixxaw

Rarity wise they're overpaying.
Their side = over 4.5 '09 rares
Your side = 1 '09 rare

[Elwynie]

Can someone please help me with this following trades?

One

Two

EDIT:

Also this? Pretty sure it's unfair but I'm not sure how the old store pet values work out, so would be grateful for an explanation!

Thank you in advance!

♡ 2008 Very Rare Tess Horse had an extended release into May 2009 
Due to the extended release it is worth another Mid 2009 Very Rare 
So the first trade is fair(:

A grinner=2 mid advents plus a '09 rare (13-17 2009 rares)
An 09 VR = 2 09 Rares
So the second trade is unfair to you by 2 09 vrs

The third trade, demand is honestly up to you
The 2013 store pets are only worth an 09 rare each but "demand" is a users choice

[Kitkat2716]

How does this look?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84925209&userid=469345&signature=m1y8_Iuaf_jUhZbwm5zgqw

Edit,

This too please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84935754&userid=469345&signature=PMGwBfGWvh7tcYIZYH8GwA

[Achlysa]

Do you think this is fair?

Please help

[MMagpie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84935725&userid=942822&signature=WrGrBiz1BQYN7mBuxixxaw
Please help!

[Elwynie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84935725&userid=942822&signature=WrGrBiz1BQYN7mBuxixxaw
Please help!

♡ Very unfair to the other end! A 2016 store pet = late '09 rare

How does this look?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84925209&userid=469345&signature=m1y8_Iuaf_jUhZbwm5zgqw

Edit,

This too please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84935754&userid=469345&signature=PMGwBfGWvh7tcYIZYH8GwA

♡ The first trade is unfair to you by 1 09 rare
09 VR = 2 09 Rares
2019 store pet = late '10 rare
2 2010 rares = 1 09 rare

The second trade is also unfair to you
An 08 VR = 2 09 Rares + 1 2010 rare
Your side = 6 09 rares