The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[- Alice -]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83988711&userid=918338&signature=_cAtLEOIWoezlOF98sIpTg

Would this be fair?

Umm, yes. The rare is the same year as the uncommon, I would definitely accept.

Please don't give false advice. That makes it unfair to the user on the top. 2-3 uncommons of the same year make up a rare

[- Alice -]

Is this fair? From what I know of C$ value, it's a bit of an overpay, but any thoughts would be appreciated

I'd like to know this as I'm on the other side ^^'

[tomocolle]

What would my 2 Very Rares and a 2009 rare (vr horse and rat, rare cat) be worth in pets and c$?

[- Alice -]

What would my 2 Very Rares and a 2009 rare (vr horse and rat, rare cat) be worth in pets and c$?

Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876

Please ask c$ worth questions here ^^" and questions on pet worth here;
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4110522

[signal]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83990148&userid=962723&signature=p4TWvATHqIftdYK9eeWQJA

Would really appreciate some help on this 😊😊

[DitsyDruid]

Which would be better for 1,330 items?
I just want to know which one's worth more rarity and demand wise!
Bid 1
Bid 2

Just to make it clear, I'm making some very broad assumptions here since I've not got nearly enough information to go off of. There are some items, for example the elvish garbs (?) from the '11 medieval faire that go for crazy overpay. If you want an accurate estimate you'll probably need to show us what we're looking at as far as the older items are concerned. There's a thread somewhere listing the more valuable items and the going rate for them but I'm too tired for that right now.

Anyway, assuming the average date of the items is '15 and they all weigh in at roughly a common in value, we're looking at somewhere around the value of 340 '15 rares. Due to the sheer bulk we'll round that up to 350. That's roughly 20 '10 rares by 2:1 maths or 5 '09 rares. Again, this is a ballpark guess.

I'd probably take the second bid and take my chances trying to trade the rats, to be honest, but based purely on the guesstimations I made they're both good offers.

Thank you! Sorry about the lack of information I was on mobile so it's a bit hard to get everything on here.
I have all the items in the auction listed here and about the only thing I can think of that's worth a bit is the 2010 CS Birthday dog plush.

[sketchelium]

Could I get a second opinion on this please? Thanks for any help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83990173&userid=361653&signature=59ciG3IkMp7q57szCE_Rvw

[- Alice -]

Is this fair? From what I know of C$ value, it's a bit of an overpay, but any thoughts would be appreciated

I'd like to know this as I'm on the other side ^^'

[Falco]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83988803&userid=841851&signature=gyk_Lg3w5G4gzKiw17Yqkg
They canceled, but would this have been fair?

Still waiting

[MidnightDuchess]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83988803&userid=841851&signature=gyk_Lg3w5G4gzKiw17Yqkg
They canceled, but would this have been fair?

Still waiting

Both pets are well sought after. If you still trade based on the list and use list values then the PPS Dragon Cat is nowhere near the worth of the blue rose dog. Demand wise they are the same, maybe the blue rose is even more sought, so the PPS could never be worth the blue rose there even

Rarity the blue rose dog is a VR from 2008 (re-release there) and the PPS dragon cat is a 2014 store pet (1 early 2009 rare)