The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Falco]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83988803&userid=841851&signature=gyk_Lg3w5G4gzKiw17Yqkg
They canceled, but would this have been fair?

[amarok.]

how does this look? i’m very tempted..

It's unfair to you by the Joker bun, since the sunback goes for roughly 3 nons and the dogtag and non would accommodate for that by themselves.

Edit; quoted wrong trade. Tired, too many tabs open, ignore everything I say from here on out haha

[_.mustard._]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83989181&userid=942822&signature=bmY1LjliGysyPhhRL3bjSg

Is this fair?

[- Alice -]

Is this fair? From what I know of C$ value, it's a bit of an overpay, but any thoughts would be appreciated

C$ value is completely irrelevant when it comes to a pet trade.
It's unfair to you by the Joker bun, since the sunback goes for roughly 3 nons and the dogtag and non would accommodate for that by themselves.

Erm wrong link /// trade? Aha

[amarok.]

Is this fair? From what I know of C$ value, it's a bit of an overpay, but any thoughts would be appreciated

C$ value is completely irrelevant when it comes to a pet trade.
It's unfair to you by the Joker bun, since the sunback goes for roughly 3 nons and the dogtag and non would accommodate for that by themselves.

Erm wrong link /// trade? Aha

Oh damn ignore me
One sec
I'm in mobile and flipping between far too many tabs fixed it haha

[Blue_Aussie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83987918&userid=709910&signature=5EyIc3-5agMqEgP3BQVbxw
Is this fair? I did send the trade, I need help!

I very much disagree with the other user that gave their opinion. You are underpaying for it. Without demand it is only worth an 09 rare. With demand, it can fetch up to a low main list pet. This is unfair to them.

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83987918&userid=709910&signature=5EyIc3-5agMqEgP3BQVbxw
Is this fair? I did send the trade, I need help!

I very much disagree with the other user that gave their opinion. You are underpaying for it. Without demand it is only worth an 09 rare. With demand, it can fetch up to a low main list pet. This is unfair to them.

They're not underpaying for it at all, they're overpaying an insane amount. They're just not the biggest bidder. And to be fair, demand for the dragon PPS is genuinely insane to this point.

Which would be better for 1,330 items?
I just want to know which one's worth more rarity and demand wise!
Bid 1
Bid 2

Just to make it clear, I'm making some very broad assumptions here since I've not got nearly enough information to go off of. There are some items, for example the elvish garbs (?) from the '11 medieval faire that go for crazy overpay. If you want an accurate estimate you'll probably need to show us what we're looking at as far as the older items are concerned. There's a thread somewhere listing the more valuable items and the going rate for them but I'm too tired for that right now.

Anyway, assuming the average date of the items is '15 and they all weigh in at roughly a common in value, we're looking at somewhere around the value of 340 '15 rares. Due to the sheer bulk we'll round that up to 350. That's roughly 20 '10 rares by 2:1 maths or 5 '09 rares. Again, this is a ballpark guess.

I'd probably take the second bid and take my chances trying to trade the rats, to be honest, but based purely on the guesstimations I made they're both good offers.

[Redpanda]

found answer thank you

[screamingrainfrog]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83988711&userid=918338&signature=_cAtLEOIWoezlOF98sIpTg

Would this be fair?

[Blue_Aussie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83988711&userid=918338&signature=_cAtLEOIWoezlOF98sIpTg

Would this be fair?

Umm, yes. The rare is the same year as the uncommon, I would definitely accept.